CRE execs debate whether this is a different real estate cycle

Los Angeles /
Jun.June 07, 2017 10:30 AM

From TRD New York: Top commercial real estate executives gathered at the Marriott Marquis hotel in Washington, D.C. to discuss how the current real estate cycle differs from the late stages of the last cycle just before the global financial crisis.

The panelists at the Commercial Real Estate Finance Council’s annual conference on Tuesday were David Durning, president and CEO of PGIM Real Estate Finance; Reid Liffmann, managing director of Angelo, Gordon & Co.; Dennis Schuh, chief originations officer at Starwood Property Trust; Real Capital Analytics’ Robert White; and Annaly Capital Management’s Michael Quinn. Eastdil Secured’s Nicholas Seidenberg led the discussion.

Because of CREFC’s restrictive media policy, the quotes and statements cannot be attributed to the panelists, who are treated as off-the-record anonymous sources.

According to one panelist, there are key differences between the current cycle and the prior one, notably that there’s less volatility and less opportunistic investing this time around. In this cycle, there is still some room for expansion, the panelist said.

Another panelist said that, as with the last cycle, whatever finally signals the end of the road is not likely to be obvious or expected. The probability of making mistakes is now higher in the current part of the cycle, he said, citing overambitious price expectations in Class B multifamily properties, one of the same mistakes he said he saw in 2007.

All of the panelists said that the current cycle would be over within five years, with one speaker expressing optimism that there were still a few strong years left. He said there’s been too much pessimism that belies the reality that pricing is still strong. And despite capital controls on wealth fleeing China, there’s been no notable drop in Asian investment in U.S. real estate so far, he said.

Another sign that the current cycle is different than the last is the crowding in the debt market, panelists said. Mezzanine lending, for example, is an increasingly stocked field, as more equity investors move into doing debt deals.

Perhaps the biggest difference between the two cycles, panelists said, is how the real estate finance industry has adjusted to what happened last time. Today, banks are less leveraged and newer regulations — like those restricting high volatility commercial real estate — make for more conservative lending practices.

The last cycle was marked by cheap and easy credit and that’s not how things work this time around, one panelist noted.

As for how close we are to the end of this cycle, only one panelist said it was basically already over. Like many a financier before him, the speaker opted for a baseball metaphor: The cycle is in extra innings, and a single run could end the game.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
The future of San Francisco’s Oceanwide Center is up in the air again (Getty, Foster and Partners)

Contractors pull out as Oceanwide Center sale falls through again

Contractors pull out as Oceanwide Center sale falls through again
Granite CEO Michael Dardick and Industrious CEO Jamie Hodari

Industrious partners with landlords to offer tenants satellite workplaces

Industrious partners with landlords to offer tenants satellite workplaces
Colorado Campus at 2041-2115 Colorado Avenue and Northwestern Mutual CEO John E. Schlifske

Northwestern Mutual picks up Santa Monica office campus for $166M

Northwestern Mutual picks up Santa Monica office campus for $166M
Prop 15 property tax measure draws millions (Credit: iStock)

Prop 15 property tax measure draws millions of dollars from for and against campaigns

Prop 15 property tax measure draws millions of dollars from for and against campaigns
Brookfield CEO Brian Kingston and 725 South Figueroa Street (Google Maps)

Brookfield lands $305M refi for Ernst & Young Plaza in DTLA

Brookfield lands $305M refi for Ernst & Young Plaza in DTLA
California is allowing barbershops and salons to reopen under new coronavirus mitigation guidelines (Credit: Noam Galai/Getty Images)

California allows barbershops to reopen, but LA holds back

California allows barbershops to reopen, but LA holds back
LA County assessor Jeffrey Prang

LA County properties valued at nearly $2 trillion…before pandemic

LA County properties valued at nearly $2 trillion…before pandemic
First District Supervisor Hilda Solis (Credit: Rebecca Sapp/Getty Images)

LA County select reopening target date for restaurants and retailers

LA County select reopening target date for restaurants and retailers
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...