City’s move to ban “granny flats” in some hillside areas prompts more debate

Calls for a total ban in those communities has been criticized as ignoring Los Angeles’ massive housing shortage

Nov.November 30, 2018 11:00 AM
Councilmember David Ryu and an ADU (Credit: Flickr)

Los Angeles city officials are recommending a ban on so-called “granny flats” in some hillside areas including upscale neighborhoods of Bel Air, Laurel Canyon and the Bird Streets.

The move on Thursday by the City Planning Commission came as part of a larger effort to regulate L.A.’s granny flats or secondary accessory dwelling units. They are separate units built on single-family parcels. Mayor Eric Garcetti has previously promoted the granny flats as one way to address the city’s severe housing shortage.

The planning commission’s recommendations would allow granny flats up to 1,200 square feet in areas in approved locations.

But lawmakers and the city are still divided over the rules.

The City Council’s Planning and Land Use Committee wants the ban expanded to all hillside areas. That’s how the committee voted last year when the planning commission proposed rules allowing ADUs in hillside areas, within a half-mile of a transit stop.

A total ban could greatly reduce the number of buildable granny flats in L.A. — 30 percent of the city’s single-family homes are located in hillside areas. Under the planning commission’s recommended smaller ban, only 6.5 percent of single-family lots would be affected. Some critics of the ban say the hillside communities, many of them in pricey neighborhoods, would be getting special treatment.

Councilmember David Ryu, who represents hillside areas including Hollywood Hills and Sherman Oaks, contends a blanket ban is a safety precaution. A representative for Ryu told the commission Thursday repeated that assertion and cited the devastation caused by the recent Woolsey Fire as one reason to not allow ADUs in vulnerable areas. Current estimates put the amount of real estate damage from the Woolsey Fire at around $5 billion[Curbed]Dennis Lynch 

Related Articles

David Ryu (Credit: Getty Images)

LA becomes 1st city to enact ban on developer money

Gavin Newsom signed bills to facilitate backyard home construction.

Yes, in my backyard: Brokers say new accessory dwelling unit law will reduce barriers to building

From left: Jose Huizar, Huang Wei, Mohamed Hadid, Robert Herscu, Raymond Chan, and Arman Gabay, with Los Angeles City Hall (Credit: iStock and Getty Images)

Real estate’s role in LA corruption scandals

Governer Gavin Newsom and homes in California (Credit: iStock and Getty Images)

Solving SoCal’s housing crisis means zoning for more than 1M new homes, the state says

From left: Governor Gavin Newsom, Assemblymember David Chiu, Senator Holly Mitchell, and Senator Nancy Skinner (Credit: Getty Images)

Here are the key housing and rent control bills state lawmakers are debating

From left: Mark Ridley-Thomas and Mayor Eric Garcetti (Credit: Office of Mayor Eric Garcetti)

LA’s affordable housing crisis linked to recent spike in homelessness

Assemblymember Phil Ting

Statewide pot shop bill gets smoked

Assemblymember David Chui

Opponents of statewide bill to cap rent increases call it “disincentive” to build