Simon and Taubman gear up for legal throwdown

Taubman will try to force its would-be acquirer to complete scuttled $3.6B deal

TRD NATIONAL /
Jun.June 11, 2020 02:00 PM
David Simon of Simon Property Group and Robert Taubman of Taubman Centers (Getty)
David Simon of Simon Property Group and Robert Taubman of Taubman Centers (Getty)

Nearly two decades ago, the Taubman family ferociously fended off a hostile takeover of their mall company from Simon Property Group. Now the roles are reversed: The Taubmans are gearing up to force Simon to complete the $3.6 billion acquisition it abandoned.

Hours after Simon announced it had scuttled the deal Wednesday, Michigan-based Taubman Centers issued a statement saying it aims to force Simon back to the table to complete the deal — or pay damages.

“Taubman believes that Simon’s purported termination of the merger agreement is invalid and without merit, and that Simon continues to be bound to the transaction in all respects,” the company’s statement read. “Taubman intends to hold Simon to its obligations … and to vigorously contest Simon’s purported termination and legal claims.”

This won’t be the first time the two see each other in court. Simon Property sued Taubman in 2002 after the latter rejected its takeout offer, claiming Taubman breached its fiduciary duty to shareholders and violated Michigan law by failing to get approval from shareholders ahead of a vote to reject the deal.

Taubman prevailed a year later, but only by lobbying Michigan lawmakers to change the state’s takeover laws in a way that favored the family.

This time, Simon Property has hired seasoned mergers-and-acquisitions attorney Lew Clayton of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison to put the final nail in the deal’s coffin.

Simon filed a lawsuit in Michigan Wednesday asking the state court to rule that Taubman breached the contract by allowing the company to suffer a materially adverse effect from the coronavirus.

Among other claims, Simon accused Taubman of refusing to cut costs as malls shuttered. Taubman failed to cut executive salaries and fire or furlough employees, according to Simon, which said it took both actions for its company.

“Taubman will pay a high price for decisions of company management that ignore the financial effects of the pandemic,” the company wrote in its lawsuit. “Taubman’s failure to take timely action means that its operations, its employees, and its other stakeholders will suffer far more in the future.”

Simon also accused Taubman of relying on “enormous borrowing” by drawing down $350 million on a line of credit in March — an action that Simon acknowledged it had approved.

Another claim is that Taubman’s portfolio of high-end, enclosed malls suffered more and will struggle to recover from the pandemic more than competitors that better diversified their portfolios with open-air shopping centers.

Because the virus spreads more readily indoors, shoppers will feel more comfortable returning to open-air centers, which tend to sell necessary goods like groceries instead of discretionary items that people can buy online, Simon argues.

CEO David Simon distanced his company from the mall label on the REIT’s May earnings call.

“We are not a mall company,” he said. “We are predominantly a retail real estate company, but we’re not — I wouldn’t, by any stretch of the imagination consider us a mall company.”

The case will be watched closely. Analysts at Piper Sandler said they believe Indianapolis-based Simon has the upper hand in the Michigan legal drama.

“While [Taubman] has the home-court advantage . . . [Simon] has the financial resources to sustain an ongoing legal battle while still reopening its portfolio,” analysts wrote in a note. “By contrast, Taubman must now grapple with this litigation and resolve reopenings with tenants, without the fiscal heft [Simon] would have provided in those negotiations.”

Contact Rich Bockmann at [email protected] or 908-415-5229


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Carson Mayor Albert Robles and a rendering of the proposed project (Credit: The city of Carson)

Simon-Macerich mall project in Carson sparks latest legal claim

Simon-Macerich mall project in Carson sparks latest legal claim
Macerich and Simon Property Group to build luxury outlet center

Macerich and Simon Property Group to build luxury outlet center

Macerich and Simon Property Group to build luxury outlet center
Robert Durst (Photo by Alex Gallardo-Pool/Getty Images)

Pandemic pushes back Robert Durst murder trial yet again

Pandemic pushes back Robert Durst murder trial yet again
(Realtor.com)

Spec mansions in Beverly Park, Beverly Hills sell at big discounts

Spec mansions in Beverly Park, Beverly Hills sell at big discounts
Jose Huizar (Getty)

Huizar indicted on 34 counts related to bribery and corruption scheme

Huizar indicted on 34 counts related to bribery and corruption scheme
Hudson Pacific Properties CEO Victor Coleman (Illustration of Victor Coleman by The Real Deal; iStock; Coleman via Hudson Pacific)

Hudson Pacific is effusive about Blackstone deal, defensive about office space

Hudson Pacific is effusive about Blackstone deal, defensive about office space
Jeff Bezos and the Beverly Hills home (Getty, Realtor)

Bezos buys Beverly Hills bungalow next to his massive mansion

Bezos buys Beverly Hills bungalow next to his massive mansion
(iStock)

SoCal developers say demand for office, retail space will continue to drop

SoCal developers say demand for office, retail space will continue to drop
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...