Fannie Mae has ignored foreclosure problems since before the crisis

Miami /
Feb.February 06, 2012 02:15 PM

When home prices were still booming earlier this decade, the foreclosure scandals that dominate the headlines today could have been averted had Fannie Mae paid more attention to one foreclosed homeowner, according to the New York Times.

Nye Lavalle, a well-to-do business professional, was preparing to pay off the $100,000 balance in 1988 on a loan he took out for a home in Dallas, Texas. But Lavalle found discrepancies in the paperwork that inflated his bill by $18,000. He refused to pay his loan servicer, and endured a long, and ultimately unsuccessful, legal process to fight the charges. In 1995 he lost the home.

For years Lavalle conducted his own personal investigation into the mortgage industry. In 1996 he found forged signatures on foreclosure documents, and over the next seven years found more instances of improper foreclosure filings initiated by the Mortgage Electric Registration.

In fact, Lavalle found that Fannie only kept about 40 percent of notes once mortgages were paid off. If a paid off note was held by another lender, it could, and in some cases did, demand money from the homeowner, even though he or she already repaid the entire loan.

Starting in 2003, Lavalle revealed his findings to Fannie Mae and held dialogues with officials for more than two years on the unlawful ways they were carrying out foreclosures. In 2006, still years before foreclosures claimed the spotlight, a law firm hired by Fannie to investigate Lavalle’s claims issued their own report that largely ccorroborated his findings.

But, according to the Times, that “is where it ended.” It appears Fannie Mae management never took action from the report, which could have preempted the troubles it’s saddled with today. [NYT]


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Variety Hotel (iStock)
Miami Beach hotel heads to foreclosure auction
Miami Beach hotel heads to foreclosure auction
Developer Louis Birdman (One Thousand Museum, Getty)
One Thousand Museum developers score $90M refi to stave off foreclosure
One Thousand Museum developers score $90M refi to stave off foreclosure
A rendering of the the property at 3601 North Miami Avenue and HES Group CEO Francisco Arocha (Photos via HES, Francisco Arocha)
Midtown Miami Triptych dev site owner files for Chapter 11 amid foreclosure
Midtown Miami Triptych dev site owner files for Chapter 11 amid foreclosure
Simon and David Reuben with One Thousand Museum (Getty, iStock)
Reuben Brothers seeks to foreclose on Zaha Hadid-designed One Thousand Museum
Reuben Brothers seeks to foreclose on Zaha Hadid-designed One Thousand Museum
Clockwise: 310-318 Northwest 25th Street, Chaim Cahane, Jonathon Yormak and Jon Krasner 
Wynwood developer sells retail property in foreclosure for $12M
Wynwood developer sells retail property in foreclosure for $12M
Miami-Dade Mayor Daniella Levine Cava (Getty, iStock)
Miami-Dade resumes pre-pandemic evictions after unannounced February break
Miami-Dade resumes pre-pandemic evictions after unannounced February break
Westime owner Jean Simonian and Washington Park Hotel. (Facebook via Westime and Washington Park Hotel)
Ladder Capital sells Witkoff’s Miami Beach hotel for $44M
Ladder Capital sells Witkoff’s Miami Beach hotel for $44M
Southland Mall in Cutler Bay (Google Maps)
Lender takes control of struggling Southland Mall in Cutler Bay
Lender takes control of struggling Southland Mall in Cutler Bay
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...