Florida Keys short-term rentals under scrutiny

Miami /
May.May 01, 2015 11:15 AM

The vacation rental website Airbnb has drawn the wrath of the official tourism agency of the Florida Keys.

A 22-page Monroe County Tourist Development Council report about unlicensed vacation rentals singles out Airbnb for its practice of not collecting sales tax and the county’s 4 percent bed tax on behalf of property owners. The TDC uses the majority of bed tax funds to promote the Keys.

The agency recommends that local governments join forces to require Airbnb to collect taxes for all transactions in Monroe County. “If Airbnb should refuse to do, file a joint lawsuit as other destinations have done,” the report says.

Prominently, Palm Beach County sued Airbnb over bed tax collections in 2014. The Palm Beach suit also named the websites HomeAway, Trip Advisor and Couchsurfing.

Vacation rentals, which are generally defined as rentals of less than 28 days, are tightly regulated throughout the Keys. In addition to state licensing requirements, the cities of Key West, Marathon and Islamorada, as well as Monroe County, require property owners to acquire a vacation rental license or permit.

Nevertheless, illegal rentals proliferate. In a 2013 interview with the Key West Citizen, Monroe County officials estimated that in unincorporated portions of the Keys alone there were 1,500 vacation rentals, of which only 50 had licenses.

Along with depriving the county of taxes, illegal rentals are a problem because they undercut licensed rental homes and lodges, and because their renters are more vulnerable to scams than those who rent regulated homes, the TDC says.

In addition to suggesting that Keys cities take a tough stance against Airbnb, the tourism agency laid out several steps it will take to curb illegal vacation rentals. Among them will be sending an email outlining local requirements to the owner of each Keys vacation rental listed on popular sites such as Airbnb, Craigslist and HomeAway.

Airbnb did not respond to a request for comment.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
A photo illustration of Icon on 8's planned short-term rental hotel along with the current site at 930-950 Southwest 8th Street in Little Havana (Getty Images, Icon on 8, Google Maps)
LA developer plans Little Havana short-term rental hotel
LA developer plans Little Havana short-term rental hotel
Ricardo Vadia, Jon Paul Perez, and Oscar Rodriguez with District 225
Developers score $76M construction loan for Airbnb-branded condos in downtown Miami
Developers score $76M construction loan for Airbnb-branded condos in downtown Miami
From left: Harvey Hernandez and Cindy Diffenderfer (NGD Homesharing, Newgard Group, iStock)
Harvey Hernandez’s NGD Homesharing hit with $963K judgment
Harvey Hernandez’s NGD Homesharing hit with $963K judgment
New York, Miami, Chicago, Los Angeles, San Francisco and Chicago (iStock)
As rent explodes nationally, Miami tops the charts
As rent explodes nationally, Miami tops the charts
Condo sales, occupancy on the rise in Greater Downtown Miami, report shows
Condo sales, occupancy on the rise in Greater Downtown Miami, report shows
Condo sales, occupancy on the rise in Greater Downtown Miami, report shows
What’s an Airbnb worth? Suit seeks nearly $3M price drop for Miami Beach building without short-term rental permit
What’s an Airbnb worth? Suit seeks nearly $3M price drop for Miami Beach building without short-term rental permit
What’s an Airbnb worth? Suit seeks nearly $3M price drop for Miami Beach building without short-term rental permit
Fruchtlander family buys Hollywood, Florida rental for $32M
Fruchtlander family buys Hollywood, Florida rental for $32M
Fruchtlander family buys Hollywood, Florida rental for $32M
Miami's Quadro in the Design District (Quadro Residences)
Alta Developers begins closings at Quadro at Design District
Alta Developers begins closings at Quadro at Design District
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...