Is the big rebound in housing rational? Perhaps not

Miami /
Jul.July 25, 2015 04:47 PM

Home prices have rebounded. They are up 27 percent nationwide since 2012 and even more in cities like San Francisco.  Do you worry about another bubble in the making? Not if you believe the classical efficient market theory that prices embody all available information about a particular asset, so higher home prices must reflect “new information,” even if you’re unaware of it.

But this type of thinking is half right, at best. Housing defies the efficient market theory, a hypothesis prevalent in the stock market, which does sometimes exhibit efficient behavior.

Economist Robert Shiller asserts that the housing market is much less rational than the stock market. He is co-founder of the widely watched S&P/Case-Shiller Home Price Index.

In a 2013 presentation at a convention of the American Economic Association, Edward L. Glaeser of Harvard University showed that real estate investors throughout history repeatedly have ignored the supplier response to increasing prices. In Alabama, for example, a cotton farmland boom from 1815 to 1819 ended when increased cotton production deflated land prices.

Edward M. Miller noted in a 1977 article in the Journal of Finance that a market cannot be efficient unless short  selling is possible.

In the stock market, for example, short sellers make money by betting correctly that stock prices will fall. But without short selling, smart investors who foresee price declines cannot profit from their foresight, except by avoiding investment in an unpromising asset class. And in the absence of short sellers,  little can prevent optimistic but uninformed investors from overvaluing an asset class, as happened in the housing market prior to the downturn of the late 2000s. [New York Times] Mike Seemuth


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Clockwise from top left: One Sotheby’s Jorge Uribe, Compass' Ida Schwartz, Fortune International Group's Edgardo Defortuna and Royal Palm Companies' Dan Kodsi (Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
Slowdown hits South Florida’s hot resi market: Here’s what that means
Slowdown hits South Florida’s hot resi market: Here’s what that means
(Illustration by The Real Deal with Getty Images)
South Florida’s June resi sales drop by double digits
South Florida’s June resi sales drop by double digits
(iStock/Illustration by The Real Deal)
Miami again ranks as nation’s least affordable housing market, followed by LA, NY
Miami again ranks as nation’s least affordable housing market, followed by LA, NY
US HUD Secretary Marcia Fudge (Getty, iStock)
A heavy crown: HUD secretary declares Miami “epicenter” of nation’s housing crisis
A heavy crown: HUD secretary declares Miami “epicenter” of nation’s housing crisis
Residential sales fall in Southern Florida
Residential sales fall in April across South Florida
Residential sales fall in April across South Florida
10061 Southwest 60th Court in Pinecrest with Dr. Robert DerHagopian (Google Maps, Miami Cancer Institute)
Miami breast cancer surgeon Robert DerHagopian sells Pinecrest house for $6M
Miami breast cancer surgeon Robert DerHagopian sells Pinecrest house for $6M
2621 Flamingo Drive in Miami Beach with Mike Hezemans and Rita and Roman Shukhman (Compass, Wikipedia, Getty, LinkedIn)
Pro race car drivers sell Miami Beach spec house for $10M
Pro race car drivers sell Miami Beach spec house for $10M
Michael Dorrell, co-founder and CEO, Stonepeak Infrastructure Partners, in front of 235 Solano Prado in Coral Gables (The Jill Zeder Group, LinkedIn/Michael Dorrell)
New York investment firm founder pays record $34M for waterfront Coral Gables teardown
New York investment firm founder pays record $34M for waterfront Coral Gables teardown
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...