Miami Beach voters say no to Ocean Terrace upzoning

Miami /
Nov.November 04, 2015 09:45 AM

Miami Beach voters have rejected a zoning change proposal aimed at increasing the allowable square footage and building height in a North Beach historic district known as Ocean Terrace.

On Tuesday, just more than 55 percent of voters said no to a ballot question that would have allowed developer Sandor Scher to build a pair of high-rises as well as extensive retail space on Ocean Terrace between 73rd and 75th streets. About 45 percent of voters supported the measure, which proponents said would revitalize what they described as a blighted and crime ridden area.

But the proposal faced stiff resistance from a coalition of preservationists and neighborhood activists, who said if the project went ahead, 11 of 13 designated historic buildings would be demolished.

The proposed zoning changes would have created an overlay district allowing for increased height limits in the area, currently restricted to 75 feet, and an increase the allowable floor area ratio (FAR) from 2.0 to 3.0 or a 50 percent increase. Scher and his main investor, Alex Blavatnik of Access Industries, have spent about $70 million buying most of the buildings on Ocean Terrace over the past two years – with the goal of eventually building a mixed-use development anchored by a condominium and hotel, as well as extensive street-level retail space on the east side of Collins Avenue. Following the vote, Scher declined to comment to The Real Deal.

Scher’s earlier renovation projects of the Raleigh Hotel, the Standard, Faena Hotel & Residences and the Essex Hotel among others have been widely praised for maintaining preservation standards and the Miami Beach commission voted to support putting the ballot question before voters. It was the first time Miami Beach voters had been asked to approve an FAR increase since a charter amendment was passed in 1997 requiring voter approval for upzoning changes in areas facing the water. The amendment was strengthened in 2001 to include inland areas as well.

The referendum was also supported by nearly all the homeowners associations in the North Beach area, but preservationists strongly objected. They, and a coalition of neighborhood activists, who said the project would bring gentrification to North Beach, organized a vigorous opposition campaign that tapped into discontent among many Miami Beach residents over the pace of development, and controversy over the power of lobbyists promoting development interests at City Hall.

Daniel Ciraldo of the Miami Design Preservation League told TRD after the vote that it was a message to developers. “I think the people of Miami Beach have spoken and they do not want upzoning and they do not want overdevelopment and they do not want our historic districts to be destroyed,” Ciraldo said.

A PAC supporting the zoning change raised $673,000, and spent $434,000 on advertising to promote it, while opponents spent about $25,000 to defeat it.

Scher has said repeatedly that he had no alternative plans for developing Ocean Terrace if the ballot question failed, but city officials have pledged to complete a master plan for all of North Beach next year which could spur a large-scale revitalization of the area.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Brookfield Asset Management CEO Bruce Flatt, Dacra president and CEO Craig Robins, L Catterton CEO James Michael Chu, and the Paradise Plaza in Miami’s Design District (Google Maps, Wikipedia, LCatterton)
Haute rent: What Gucci, Dior and others pay in Miami’s Design District
Haute rent: What Gucci, Dior and others pay in Miami’s Design District
Planned Waldorf Astoria Miami wins design approval
Planned Waldorf Astoria Miami wins design approval
Planned Waldorf Astoria Miami wins design approval
Rendering of N29 project as seen from NW 29th Street and 1st Avenue and Carpe Real Estate Partners co-founder David Weitz (L&L Carpe Wynwood Holdings)
Miami board rejects design for massive Wynwood mixed-use project, N29
Miami board rejects design for massive Wynwood mixed-use project, N29
https://therealdeal.com/sanfrancisco/2021/10/19/sf-planning-commission-chooses-laundry-over-housing/
Surfside collapse mediation hits standoff, as rival sides dig in heels on disbursements
Surfside collapse mediation hits standoff, as rival sides dig in heels on disbursements
Don Peebles, Michael Swerdlow and a rendering of the development (Black 55)
Don Peebles drops remaining $160M claims tied to Overtown development lawsuit
Don Peebles drops remaining $160M claims tied to Overtown development lawsuit
Lissette Calderon and renderings of The Julia (Neology Life)
Lissette Calderon scores $78M construction loan for second Allapattah multifamily project
Lissette Calderon scores $78M construction loan for second Allapattah multifamily project
From left: Cavalli Tower with Hussain Sajwani of Damac and the Surfside condo collapse site (Damac, Wikimedia, Getty)
From Dubai to Surfside: Inside Damac’s plans to redevelop the tragic site
From Dubai to Surfside: Inside Damac’s plans to redevelop the tragic site
Pompano Beach mixed-use project scores $45M construction loan
Pompano Beach mixed-use project scores $45M construction loan
Pompano Beach mixed-use project scores $45M construction loan
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...