Starwood would face problems closing a deal with Anbang

There's no guarantee a purchase agreement would be enforced by Chinese courts

TRD MIAMI /
Mar.March 31, 2016 02:15 PM

From the New York website: If Anbang Insurance Group wins its bidding war for Starwood Hotels & Resorts, the hospitality firm would still have a lot of work to do to ensure the deal closes. 

When financing or other issues arise, parties generally enforce purchase agreements through the courts, but there are myriad difficulties in suing a firm such Anbang – with most of its assets based in China – for the colossal $14 billion sum that Anbang has offered, the New York Times reported.

The rule of law is notoriously weak in China, and it’s not clear that a Chinese court would enforce a judgement against Anbang. But Starwood still has options.

Many companies doing business internationally – especially in other weak-rule-of-law countries such as Russia – have included contract provisions mandating binding arbitration to settle disputes, instead of the courts.

About 24 national governments around the world, including China’s, have signed on to the 1958 United Nations Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards, known as the New York Convention.

But still, it’s widely believed even this sort of decision doesn’t amount to a guarantee in the case of China, the Times reported. And even if Chinese courts went along, the process would likely take years, far longer than Starwood can afford.

Another avenue for Starwood is demanding that Anbang put up collateral. The problem is that Anbang’s combined assets outside of China – the largest of those being the Waldorf Astoria Hotel, which it bought for $1.95 billion in 2014, and the Strategic Hotels and Resorts portfolio it recently bought from Blackstone for $6.5 billion – don’t add up to the value of its $14 billion bid.

Starwood’s lawyers would likely seek a deposit or letter of credit as collateral, the Times reported. Anbang’s opaque ownership structure makes collecting deposits from shareholders unlikely, but the firms could follow the lead of Shuanghui International Holdings, who placed a $275 million termination fee in escrow when it bought Smithfield Foods in 2013, about 5 percent of the purchase price.

Starwood may seek a larger escrow deposit, largely composed of letters of credit and financing letters rather than cash.

There are also likely to be problems with regulatory permission and financing for the purchase, the Times reported.

All these factors suggest Marriott International’s $13.6 billion bid may be relatively more attractive than Anbang’s, despite being lower. [NYT]Ariel Stulberg


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Hyde Beach House Resort & Residences, Carlos Rosso and Drew Sims

Sotherly closes on acquisition of Hyde Beach House hotel space

Sotherly closes on acquisition of Hyde Beach House hotel space
Daily Digest Miami

Developers clear first hurdle in massive casino redevelopment, FPL fuels up with Homestead farmland for natural gas facility: Daily digest

Developers clear first hurdle in massive casino redevelopment, FPL fuels up with Homestead farmland for natural gas facility: Daily digest
Daily Digest Miami

Chicken Soup for the Soul publisher sells Deerfield Beach properties, pollutants discovered at new Miami Civil Courthouse: Daily digest

Chicken Soup for the Soul publisher sells Deerfield Beach properties, pollutants discovered at new Miami Civil Courthouse: Daily digest
Daniel Rutois and Hyde Resort and Residences

Hyde Resort & Residences association strikes back at Sotherly Hotels

Hyde Resort & Residences association strikes back at Sotherly Hotels
Daniel Rutois and Hyde Resort and Residences

Sotherly Hotels sues Hyde Resort & Residences association president

Sotherly Hotels sues Hyde Resort & Residences association president
With SoFla condo sales down, developers sweeten pot for buyers and brokers

With SoFla condo sales down, developers sweeten pot for buyers and brokers

With SoFla condo sales down, developers sweeten pot for buyers and brokers
InterContinental Miami among U.S. hotels that Chinese regulators may sell

InterContinental Miami among U.S. hotels that Chinese regulators may sell

InterContinental Miami among U.S. hotels that Chinese regulators may sell
China said to be taking offers for a handful of Anbang’s former US hotels

China said to be taking offers for a handful of Anbang’s former US hotels

China said to be taking offers for a handful of Anbang’s former US hotels
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...