Six years on, Kolter Signature Homes lawsuit goes to trial

Miami /
Sep.September 26, 2016 12:00 PM

After six years of legal maneuvering one of the longest-running cases over faulty construction in Florida is finally going to trial.  

Jury selection starts Tuesday in a case pitting the San Matera Condominium Association against Kolter Signature Homes, and other defendants for alleged sub-standard architecture, engineering and construction work at San Matera at the Gardens, located just off PGA Boulevard in Palm Beach Gardens in Palm Beach County.

More than 30 lawyers have worked on the case over the years, and the trial will be held in a specially modified courtroom in Delray Beach in order to accommodate the large number of defendants, lawyers and plaintiffs.   

David Haber, of Haber Slade, the Miami-based firm that is representing the San Matera Condo association, said his firm is seeking $36 million in damages from Kolter and other defendants. He said Kolter Signature Homes reorganized behind The Grand at Palm Beach Gardens, a limited liability Delaware-based corporation, but that Kolter served as both the developer and contractor on the project. “The main defendant is the Grand, and Kolter Signature Homes, the contractor, because Kolter Signature Homes built it,” said Haber.   

Kolter itself has sued a number of sub-contractors on the project, but Haber said ultimately Kolter is responsible for what happened at San Matera. “The court has issued rulings already that the developer and the contractor can’t waive away their statutory obligations under the condominium act, nor can the general contractor push off on someone else their obligation to build within the building code.”

Michael Hornreich, of the Orlando-based firm Weinberg Wheeler, who is representing Kolter Homes, declined to comment on the case.    

Condo owners say years after they moved into their units, water continues to leak though sliding glass doors, and windows down to foundation slabs. Jackie Durham, the San Matera condo board president, said owners have already spent about $2 million on repairs, to fix structural damage that was largely hidden from view when the owners bought their units because much of it was behind exterior walls or in roof areas.  

“It’s really bad, we’re having to take stucco off and replace plywood sheeting, which is usually soaking wet, with rusting stubs, down to the substrate,” Durham said. “We just had a board meeting and a man said water was leaking into his bedroom.”


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
From left: John Clancy, 12034 Corozo Court in Palm Beach Gardens and William Weisberg (Photos via Providence Equity; ADHQ; Redfin)
Private equity honcho sells Palm Beach Gardens home for $5M
Private equity honcho sells Palm Beach Gardens home for $5M
Thor Chairman Joe Sitt, Stefano Ricci CEO Niccolo Ricci and the Miami store. (Getty, Thor, Miami Design District)
Thor Equities sued over alleged unpaid loan on Stefano Ricci Miami Design District store
Thor Equities sued over alleged unpaid loan on Stefano Ricci Miami Design District store
Gil Dezer and renderings of the project (Renderings via Zyscovich Architects)
Neighbors sue to overturn approval of Dezer’s mega project in North Miami Beach
Neighbors sue to overturn approval of Dezer’s mega project in North Miami Beach
Serena Williams with 7703 Bold Lad Road and 6431 River Pointe Way (Getty, Google Maps)
Serena Williams sells Palm Beach Gardens home after buying Yadier Molina’s Jupiter mansion
Serena Williams sells Palm Beach Gardens home after buying Yadier Molina’s Jupiter mansion
Jeffrey Soffer and Turnberry Isle Yacht and Racquet Club
Turnberry Isle condo association sues Jeffrey Soffer affiliate over lobby repairs
Turnberry Isle condo association sues Jeffrey Soffer affiliate over lobby repairs
Robert Lapidus and David Levinson with 333 Central Gardens Circle, Palm Beach Gardens (Getty, Central Gardens)
L&L founders pay $47M for Palm Beach Gardens apartments
L&L founders pay $47M for Palm Beach Gardens apartments
An Altmed Müv dispensary in Apollo Beach (Altmed, iStock)
Miami Beach faces new legal challenges over medical marijuana restrictions
Miami Beach faces new legal challenges over medical marijuana restrictions
Olen Properties's Igor Olenicoff and Northwestern's John Schlifske with 4045 Central Gardens Way, Palm Beach Gardens (Getty, Twitter)
Olen Properties pays $80M for Palm Beach Gardens apartments
Olen Properties pays $80M for Palm Beach Gardens apartments
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...