Forty investors who bought rooms in Miami Beach’s Shelborne Hotel lose contentious lawsuit

Miami /
Jan.January 24, 2017 06:00 PM

Five years after suing Miami Beach hotelier Keith Menin, their condo association and companies tied to developer Russell Galbut for allegedly authorizing nearly $30 million in illegal assessments to renovate and repair the Shelborne Hotel, 40 investors who bought rooms in the historic property have lost their battle.

Miami-Dade Circuit Court Judge Beatrice Butchko last Friday issued a final judgment in favor of the defendants Menin, Joan Brent, Justo Carlos Padron, Martin Wasserman, and the Shelborne Ocean Beach Hotel Condominium Association, Shelborne Property Associates and Shelborne Operating Associates.

State incorporation records show Galbut is a manager for Shelborne Property and Shelborne Operating. Ronald Rosengarten, a Greenberg Traurig shareholder who represented the Galbut entities, said Butchko’s ruling confirms that the assessments were proper, appropriate and above board.

“Shelborne Property Associates, Shelborne Operating Associates and condo association board members have endured years of unwarranted personal attacks on their character and reputation by the plaintiffs,” Rosengarten said in a statement. “All Shelborne unit owners should be pleased that their investment has been enhanced by owning units in a building whose commercial areas have been totally and beautifully refurbished, and where life-safety and aging conditions have been responsibly addressed and rectified.”

Kevin Malek, lead attorney for the 40 owners, said his clients plan to appeal Butchko’s ruling, as well as her earlier decisions to dismiss most of the counts against the defendants. He declined further comment.

Officially known as the Shelborne South Beach, the hotel is a historic Art Deco building that has gone through an extensive renovation that the 40 owners alleged was done in violation of Florida law. The landmark property has been a condo hotel for more than 10 years. Investors who purchased rooms rent the units out to tourists.

The lawsuit had alleged, among other things, that the association and certain board members breached their fiduciary duty in assessing unit owners for construction work that did not constitute necessary repairs and maintenance, and which therefore required a vote of all unit owners. The plaintiffs accused the association and board members of conspiring with Shelborne Property Associates and Shelborne Operating Associates to have the unit owners pay for construction that allegedly was done for the benefit of  the two entities’ hotel program.

According to Rosengarten and Alice K. Sum, a Fowler White Burnett shareholder who represented the condo board, the 40 owners failed to produce evidence to support their claims. Sum said the association properly performed its duties and assessed owners for the work to the common areas to address a number of required life-safety and maintenance issues for the benefit of all unit owners.

“That work included sealing fire wall separations, and replacing old wiring, rusted water pipes and other components that had substantially deteriorated or reached the end of their useful life,” Sum said in a statement. “We are very pleased with the outcome of this case.”


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
David Martin and Russell Galbut with a rendering of 500 Alton Road
Miami Beach developers nab $345M construction loan for 500 Alton
Miami Beach developers nab $345M construction loan for 500 Alton
Jefferson Brackin, Russell Galbut and Marisa Galbut (GFO Investments, NoBe Creek LLC)
Galbut development group scores approval for mixed-use North Beach resi project
Galbut development group scores approval for mixed-use North Beach resi project
Mark Gold, Keith Menin and the property at on West Rivo Alto Drive. (Luxe Living Realty, Tumblr via Mark Gold Ticket Clinic, Menin Hospitality)
Ticket Clinic founder sells Venetian Islands mansion to Keith Menin for $21M
Ticket Clinic founder sells Venetian Islands mansion to Keith Menin for $21M
Russell Galbut and Michael S. Liebowitz (iStock)
Two SPACs led by Russell Galbut and Michael Liebowitz each file for $100M IPOs
Two SPACs led by Russell Galbut and Michael Liebowitz each file for $100M IPOs
Matis Cohen and Russell Galbut with the original building and a rendering of the Normandy Isles project
Matis Cohen, Russell Galbut score approval for Normandy Isles project in Miami Beach
Matis Cohen, Russell Galbut score approval for Normandy Isles project in Miami Beach
Jared Galbut, Keith Menin and the Bentley South Beach (The Bentley Hotel)
Lawsuit against Jared Galbut, Keith Menin alleging fraudulent special assessments at Bentley South Beach moves forward
Lawsuit against Jared Galbut, Keith Menin alleging fraudulent special assessments at Bentley South Beach moves forward
A rendering of the Byron Carlyle Cultural Center, Jared Galbut and Keith Menin (Miami Beach City Commission, Google Maps)
It’s curtains for Galbut family-led proposal to redevelop Byron Carlyle Theater
It’s curtains for Galbut family-led proposal to redevelop Byron Carlyle Theater
From left: David Martin, Aby Rosen, Jorge Perez, Barry Sternlicht, Victor Ballestas and Russell Galbut (Getty)
Developers bet on long-term demand for Class A Miami Beach office space
Developers bet on long-term demand for Class A Miami Beach office space
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...