Court rules in favor of Platinum Luxury Auctions, reverses previous ruling with Concierge Auctions

Concierge previously alleged Platinum sent 17 "sabotage packages" to clients, brokers and media contacts

Miami /
Aug.August 17, 2017 02:30 PM

UPDATED, 11:36 a.m., Aug. 18: A years-long saga between rival auction houses took another turn on Wednesday.

The Third District Court of Appeal reversed a lower court ruling in favor of Miami-based Platinum Luxury Auctions LLC, led by Trayor Lesnock.

Concierge Auctions LLC, a New York-based auction house, previously alleged that Platinum sabotaged its rival’s $7.5 million deal and defamed Concierge principal Chad Roffers, according to the Daily Business Review. A lower court had ruled in favor of Concierge, ordering Platinum to remove a disparaging post about Concierge in a January 2014 article after both parties had settled. The court ruled to enforce the settlement agreement.

On Wednesday, a Third DCA judge found that an online comment created by Lesnock preceded their agreement and was not part of the settlement, the Daily Business Review reported.

Among the previous allegations? Concierge charged that Platinum sent 17 “Federal Express sabotage packages” to clients, brokers and media contacts that included articles and disparaging comments about Roffers. Lesnock even admitted to using a pseudonym to post negative comments online.

Attorney Ryan H. Lehrer, who represents Platinum Luxury Auctions, said the court’s decision this week “had nothing to do with the unproven and contested allegations in the lawsuit filed by Concierge Auctions LLC; rather, the opinion solely concentrated on the fact that Platinum Luxury Auctions had not breached the parties’ settlement agreement and the fact that Concierge Auctions LLC had wrongfully attempted to insert additional terms into that agreement that did not exist.”

Lehrer said the motion to enforce the settlement agreement filed by Concierge “years after the lawsuit settled was just the latest attempt by that entity to harass Platinum Luxury Auctions with meritless accusations and legal filings.”

Both auction houses have been active in South Florida. [Daily Business Review] – Katherine Kallergis

An earlier version of this story incorrectly stated that the Third DCA ruled in favor of Concierge Auctions on Wednesday. It ruled in favor of Platinum Luxury Auctions. 


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
From left: Sotheby’s Daniel de la Vega and Reagan Jefferies with Brevard County
One Sotheby’s picks up Brevard County brokerage
One Sotheby’s picks up Brevard County brokerage
10181 US Highway 98 West and 39 Sandy Dunes Circle (LoopNet)
Florida Panhandle estate sold for $25M
Florida Panhandle estate sold for $25M
Netscape co-founder Jim Clark and 2000 South Ocean Boulevard in Manalapan (Getty, Sotheby's)
Manalapan compound poised to sell for Florida-record $175M
Manalapan compound poised to sell for Florida-record $175M
Hussain Sajwani of Damac with Surfside (Wikipedia)
Damac to buy Surfside collapse site for $120M — no other bidders for property
Damac to buy Surfside collapse site for $120M — no other bidders for property
DAMAC Properties' Hussain Sajwani and aerial view of Surfside Towers remaining foundation of condominium after collapse (Hussain Sajwani, Getty Images)
Surfside collapse site auction set for May 24
Surfside collapse site auction set for May 24
Hassan Whiteside and 528 Lakeview Court in Miami Beach (Getty, Joe Azar/Compass)
NBA’s Hassan Whiteside lists Miami home for $23M, triple what he paid for it
NBA’s Hassan Whiteside lists Miami home for $23M, triple what he paid for it
(ONE Sotheby's Realty)
Former mayor George “Bud” Scholl’s waterfront home hits market for $13.9M
Former mayor George “Bud” Scholl’s waterfront home hits market for $13.9M
From left: American Shoal Lighthouse, Sombrero Key Lighthouse and Carysfort Reef Lighthouse (Photos via U.S. General Services Administration)
Historic lighthouse homes being sold at auction in the Florida Keys
Historic lighthouse homes being sold at auction in the Florida Keys
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...