Court rules that insurers must treat notice of claim for construction defects as a “suit”

The Florida Supreme Court ruled on a case centering on construction of the Sapphire Condominium in Fort Lauderdale and Altman Contractors Inc.

Miami /
Jan.January 21, 2018 09:00 AM

The Sapphire Condominium in Fort Lauderdale (Credit: Keller Williams Realty)

The Florida Supreme Court ruled that filing notice of a claim for a construction defect is equivalent to a filing a “suit” that a general liability insurer may have to defend.

The ruling came in response to a question about the state’s procedural requirements before filing a court claim for a construction defect.

The case centered on the Sapphire Condominium, a high-rise condo in Fort Lauderdale on North Ocean Boulevard.

In 2012, Altman Contractors Inc., the general contractor for the construction of Sapphire, got several notices of claim in 2012 from Sapphire owners, who alleged more than 800 construction defects.

Altman notified its commercial liability insurer of the Sapphire notices of claim and demanded that the insurer defend and indemnify the general contractor against the allegations of defective construction.

But the insurer, Crum & Forster Specialty Insurance Company (C&F), denied Altman’s demand, asserting the notices of claim didn’t amount to a “suit,” which would invoke the insurer’s duty to defend and indemnify the general contractor.

Altman ultimately settled all the Sapphire claims out of court without the involvement of C&F.

Altman also asked the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida to rule that C&F had a duty to provide defense and indemnity against the Sapphire claims. The district court ruled in favor of the insurer, and Altman appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit.

The appellate court responded by certifying a question for the Florida Supreme Court about chapter 558, Florida Statutes, which lays out a notice-and-repair process that must happen before claimants can sue for construction defects.

The Florida Supreme Court ruled that the notice-and-repair process that Sapphire initiated was a “suit” within the meaning of the general liability insurance policy that Altman bought from C&F. [Daily Business Review]Mike Seemuth


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
A photo illustration of the letter unit owners of Champlain Towers South in Surfside sent to the court (Getty Images, iStock)
Surfside collapse unit owners ask court to up their $83M payout
Surfside collapse unit owners ask court to up their $83M payout
Tate Capitals' Jimmy Tate and 801 Seabreeze Boulevard in Fort Lauderdale (Tate Capital, Google Maps)
Developer Jimmy Tate’s proposed Bahia Mar project faces more controversy with filing of new lawsuit
Developer Jimmy Tate’s proposed Bahia Mar project faces more controversy with filing of new lawsuit
Jules Trump and Suffolk CEO and chairman John Fish with a rendering of the Estates at Acqualina (Getty, Suffolk, Avra)
Trump Group, Suffolk Construction sue each other over Estates at Acqualina
Trump Group, Suffolk Construction sue each other over Estates at Acqualina
The $125 million Grove Central project going up next to the Coconut Grove Metrorail Station (RSM Design)
Top 10 development projects in Miami-Dade in 2021
Top 10 development projects in Miami-Dade in 2021
From left: Alejandro Diaz Bazan, David Solomon, Brett Harris and Ana Bozovic (Andian Group, Brett Harris Homes, Miami Girls, iStock)
Build it and they will come: Resi agents join the South Florida spec home development craze
Build it and they will come: Resi agents join the South Florida spec home development craze
Surfside collapse defendants deflect responsibility in new court docs
Surfside collapse defendants deflect responsibility in new court docs
Surfside collapse defendants deflect responsibility in new court docs
Chicago firm plans apartments, commercial complex on Edgewater OZ site
Chicago firm plans apartments, commercial complex on Edgewater OZ site
Chicago firm plans apartments, commercial complex on Edgewater OZ site
Miami-Dade County hit with lawsuit over West Kendall resi project approval
Save Calusa nonprofit sues Miami-Dade over golf course redevelopment
Save Calusa nonprofit sues Miami-Dade over golf course redevelopment
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...