Rent-to-own franchisee opts to buy Palm Beach home

Non-waterfront home sold for $8.15M, or about $1,500 psf

412 Australian Avenue (Credit: Redfin)
412 Australian Avenue (Credit: Redfin)

The family that controls the largest franchisee of Aaron’s rent-to-own stores paid $8.15 million for a non-waterfront home in Palm Beach, property records show.

Alina Porter sold the five-bedroom, 5,296-square-foot house at 412 Australian Avenue to the trust of Charles A. Smithgall IV, managed by trustees Ray Simmons and Thomas Beard, for $1,539 per foot. Simmons is president of the Smithgall family office, according to his LinkedIn profile. The family is the largest franchisee of Aaron’s Inc., a major rent-to-own retailer.

412 Australian Avenue (Credit: Redfin)

412 Australian Avenue (Credit: Redfin)

Porter owned the Palm Beach property with her late husband, Herbert. He owned a printing press company, Howard Press, which he sold in the late 1990’s.

Sign Up for the undefined Newsletter

By signing up, you agree to TheRealDeal Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy.

According to property records, the Porters paid $3.7 million for the house in 2004. The Mediterranean-style home was built a year earlier with high ceilings, intricate moldings, fireplaces, and a winding staircase. The property includes a pool, two-car garage and a gated entrance.

412 Australian Avenue (Credit: Redfin)

412 Australian Avenue (Credit: Redfin)

Carole Koeppel of Sotheby’s International Realty represented the seller, and Ann Summers of Brown Harris Stevens of Palm Beach brought the buyer, according to Redfin.

Non-waterfront homes in the town of Palm Beach are known to fetch high prices. In April, former magazine publisher and widow of the prominent Boston restaurateur Charlie Sarkis paid $7.4 million for a house at 171 Dunbar Road.