Financially troubled Hotel Astor in Miami Beach listed for sale

The ground lessee completed $9M in renovations in 2014 using EB-5 money from Brazil, China and Venezuela

Aug.August 12, 2019 02:30 PM
Hotel Astor (Credit: Groupon)

Hotel Astor (Credit: Groupon)

UPDATED, Aug. 13, 9 p.m.: The financially troubled and now-closed Hotel Astor is on the market for $12 million.

The 42-room, three-story hotel at 956 Washington Avenue was renovated in 2014 using $9 million raised from EB-5 investors. It closed nearly a year ago after the ground lessor, 1651 Astor LLC, filed a lawsuit to evict the hotel from the property.

The leasehold interest in the property is listed for $12 million, or nearly $286,000 per key. David J. Hart, the previous owner of Astor EB-5 LLC, the lessee, stepped down in April, court records show. Astor EB-5 filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in November.

The Art Deco hotel was built in 1936 and was designed by T. Hunter Henderson. The property includes a private pool and courtyard, fitness room and a 5,000-square-foot restaurant and bar.

The court would have to approve the sale of the hotel. Because it was remodeled in 2014, the property doesn’t need to be renovated. About 90 years remain on the ground lease at a cost of about $39,500 per month, triple net, according to an offering memorandum.

Hart, an attorney, raised money via investors from Brazil, China and Venezuela. The project was granted EB-5 status in 2015. The The EB-5 program allows foreign investors to get a green card in exchange for investing at least $500,000 in a U.S. enterprise and creating at least 10 jobs.

According to court filings, Hart “regularly commingled personal funds with those of the business and otherwise used the hotel as his own personal piggybank,” which led to the business losing money, the debtor in possession is alleging.

Prior to the Chapter 11 filing, the hotel was sued by a number of entities, many of which alleged they were owed money from Astor EB-5 LLC. SMS Lodging, which was hired to manage the hotel, sued in April 2018 for nearly $163,000 of allegedly unpaid bills. Allen, Norton & Blue, P.A., a law firm, filed suit over nearly $17,000 in unpaid legal bills. And former employees also sued the lessee.

In November, new rules governing the EB-5 program will go into effect. Earlier this year, the Trump administration released changes to the federal cash-for-visas program. The minimum that an investor has to put into a project in high-unemployment areas will jump to $900,000. The new rules will also make it more difficult for developers and state governments to gerrymander census tracts together to qualify real estate developments in areas that may not otherwise meet the program’s unemployment requirements.

Correction: An earlier version of this story incorrectly stated that Manny Chamizo of One Sotheby’s International Realty was hired to sell the property. There is no listing agent, according to Adam Skolnik, the bankruptcy attorney for Astor EB-5 LLC. 

Related Article

Robert Matthews and Palm House Hotel

Embattled Palm House developer Robert Matthews agrees to federal securities charges

From left: Jay Roberts, Keith Menin andRussell Galbut

Russell Galbut, Keith Menin ink deal with short-term rental operator Domio

Rendering of the Moxy Hotel, Pierre Charalambides and David Grutman (Credit: Kobi Karp)

Wynwood is getting its own Moxy hotel

Regency Hotel Miami (Credit: Google Maps)

Regency Miami near Beckham’s planned soccer complex trades for $26M

An aerial view of damage caused by Hurricane Dorian (Credit: Getty Images)

Tourism-dependent Bahamas sees uphill battle to rebuild hotels after Hurricane Dorian’s devastation

Academica founder Fernando Zulueta and rendering of Somerset Academy Parkland (Credit: Blue Ridge Rendering)

Parkland charter school scores $15M in EB-5-backed financing

6747 Collins Avenue, Stefano Santoro, Miguel Pinto, Charlie Porchetto and Diego Colmenero

China City Construction site in North Beach sells to hotel developer for $40M

Rendering of the Brickell hotel development, Tony Cho and Robert Finvarb

Finvarb and Cho land construction loan for mixed-use hotel near Brickell City Centre