Miami may be closer to banning Special Area Plans

SAP legislation enabled developers to pursue mega-projects, but activists argue such development is destroying neighborhoods

Miami /
Dec.December 05, 2019 01:30 PM
Renderings of Brickell City Centre and Magic City

Renderings of Brickell City Centre and Magic City

In Miami, property owners who control more than 9 acres of land can apply for a wide array of zoning changes. They’re called Special Area Plans, or SAPs, and the legislation has allowed for massive, planned projects like Brickell City Centre, River Landing Shops & Residences, the redevelopment of the Miami Design District, and the expansion of the Miami Jewish Home. It has also allowed for future mega-projects like the Magic City Innovation District in Little Haiti, Miami Produce Center in Allapattah, and Mana Wynwood.

On Jan. 15, the city of Miami’s Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board will discuss proposed legislation that could do away with SAPs altogether.

Rendering of Brickell City Center

Rendering of Brickell City Center

The board voted Wednesday to discuss a rule at its Jan. 15 meeting that would recommend that the city remove SAPs from the Miami 21 zoning code. In the 8 to 1 vote, board member Chris Collins was the lone dissenter.

The ultimate decision on whether to keep SAPs rests with the Miami City Commission. But even if the resolution isn’t approved, board members hope that it will tell elected leaders that SAPs are not beneficial to Miami’s existing neighborhoods and residents.

“I don’t want to send them a weak message,” said the resolution’s proposer, board member Alex Dominguez. “Either get rid of the damn thing … or let us move on.”

Several residents and community activists said SAPs are threatening neighborhoods, clogging roads with additional traffic, and speeding up gentrification. At the very least, community activists want a moratorium on future SAPs until regulations are put in place that govern development and require that affordable housing be offered in exchange for zoning.

“When I sell my home, I will have to leave because I will not be able to afford to live here,” said Jordan Levin, who lives in a house in Buena Vista East that she bought 20 years ago. “Please put a moratorium on these things. They’re the Godzillas of development. Development should not just be for the developers. Development should be for the city.”

Rendering of Magic City

Rendering of Magic City

Sue Trone, the city’s chief of community planning, argued that SAPs can help parts of Miami move away from the “segregated” uses advocated in the city’s 1959 comprehensive plan into a more mixed-use, pedestrian-friendly environment. And while reforms are needed, Trone argued that SAPs can “do a lot of good for the city.” Land use attorney Neisen Kasdin also begged the board not to “throw the baby out with the bath water” and to instead pursue reforms.

Dominguez, though, said it was best if the city rid itself of SAPs as soon as possible. “Time is our biggest enemy. The more time we spend kicking things down the road and having meetings, the more developers are going to develop [SAPs] and we’ll have more traffic and we’ll see more people getting displaced,” he said.

Board member Melody Torrens said stopping future SAPs is “starting to make a lot of sense.” Still, she said the commission might not accept the idea, and while reforms are being debated, developers will continue to push SAPs. “If we’re not going to stop them completely, then we definitely need a moratorium while we go through [the legislation],” Torrens said.

Board chairman Charles Garavaglia agreed with Dominguez that passing a rule ending SAPs would make a stronger impact with politicians. “I just think we should stop SAPs and send that message,” Garavaglia said, “and, ultimately, the commission will do what they want.”


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
From left: Rockpoint Group's co-founders Bill Walton and Keith Gelb in front of 1221 Brickell Avenue (Rockpoint Group, Google Maps, iStock)
Rockpoint sells 1221 Brickell office tower for $287M, marking a six-year record price
Rockpoint sells 1221 Brickell office tower for $287M, marking a six-year record price
R & B Realty’s Shelby Rosenberg and The Gateway at Wynwood (R & B Realty Group, iStock)
Lease roundup: The Gateway at Wynwood scores three new tenants
Lease roundup: The Gateway at Wynwood scores three new tenants
Related's Stephen Ross, Swire's Kieran Bowers and a rendering of One Brickell City Centre (Getty, Swire Properties)
Swire, Stephen Ross’ Related plan Florida’s tallest commercial tower in Miami’s Brickell
Swire, Stephen Ross’ Related plan Florida’s tallest commercial tower in Miami’s Brickell
Michael Stern with rendering of 1 Southside Park (DS Development Group and SHoP Architects)
Michael Stern’s JDS lands $86M loan for planned mixed-use Brickell high-rise
Michael Stern’s JDS lands $86M loan for planned mixed-use Brickell high-rise
Black Lion’s Robert Rivani with 801 Brickell Avenue (Black Lion Investment Group)
Robert Rivani’s Black Lion sells Brickell restaurant space for $13M
Robert Rivani’s Black Lion sells Brickell restaurant space for $13M
(JDS Development, OKO Group, Cain International, PMG, Sieger Suarez Architects)
Here’s the pipeline of resi projects in Miami’s Brickell
Here’s the pipeline of resi projects in Miami’s Brickell
MFG co-founders, Jeff Zalaznick, Mario Carbone, and Rich Torrisi with Michael Stern and renderings of their planned Brickell Tower at 888 Brickell Avenue (JDS, Getty)
JDS, Major Food Group to launch condo sales of Brickell skyscraper
JDS, Major Food Group to launch condo sales of Brickell skyscraper
Nuveen CEO Jose Minaya and 801 Brickell Avenue in Miami (Nuveen, Colliers)
Lease roundup: Nuveen moving Southeast HQ to 801 Brickell
Lease roundup: Nuveen moving Southeast HQ to 801 Brickell
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...