Norman Braman and Jorge Perez score court victory against Edgewater Jai Alai fronton

West Flagler Associates’ has resubmitted settlement offer that includes stipulation that new pari-mutuel site will not have slot machines

Miami /
Jan.January 21, 2021 03:30 PM
Norman Braman, Jorge Perez and Magic City Jai Alai (Google Maps, Getty, jai alai player via Wikimedia Commons)

Norman Braman, Jorge Perez and Magic City Jai Alai (Google Maps, Getty, jai alai player via Wikimedia Commons)

A campaign led by auto dealership mogul Norman Braman and developer Jorge Perez to stop a Jai Alai fronton and card room from being developed in Miami’s Edgewater neighborhood was dealt a winning hand earlier this week.

On Tuesday, Miami-Dade Circuit Court Judge Michael Hanzman ruled the City of Miami unlawfully approved a settlement with West Flagler Associates, owners of Magic City Casino and other gambling sites in the city, to let the company build the fronton and card room on a property at 3030 Biscayne Boulevard owned by Crescent Heights, the development firm headed by Russell Galbut.

Hanzman determined that Miami City Attorney Vicky Mendez erroneously opined that Miami Mayor Francis Suarez’s Feb. 21, 2020 veto of the West Flagler settlement was not applicable because the city commission’s approval of the agreement did not constitute a land use decision per the city’s charter.

“The court concludes that the commission’s decision to enter into this settlement agreement was a ‘land use decision’ as that phrase would be understood by the average citizen,” Hanzman wrote. “The decision to give the mayor this broad veto power was carefully considered and enacted into law because ‘land use decisions’ can dramatically impact the health and well-being of a community.”

In an email statement, Mendez said the city is still evaluating what it’s next step will be, including a possible appeal. “We appreciate Judge Hanzman’s efforts in trying to clarify the complex issues in this case,” Mendez said. “We are reviewing the court’s order to determine how best to proceed in light of the ruling.”

In a written statement, Braman said he and the other plaintiffs are pleased with Hanzman’s decision. In March of last year, entities controlled by Braman and Perez joined forces with two homeowner associations to sue the city and West Flagler. “With help from the mayor and commission, Miami has become a world class city and is on the precipice of further transformational leaps,” Braman said. “The last thing our city needs is the plight and desolation that come with casino gambling.”

Joseph DeMaria, a partner with Fox Rothschild representing West Flagler, said his client doesn’t want to appeal Hanzman’s ruling and would prefer to redo the process for approving the settlement agreement, which would involve another vote by the city commission and a possible second veto from Suarez. The difference is that this time, his clients want the city commission to vote on overriding the mayor’s veto by a supermajority, DeMaria said during a phone interview.

“If we get to that point and the city commission does override a veto, great,” DeMaria said. “If it doesn’t get overridden, then we will go to trial and we believe we will win.”

The settlement agreement had put the brakes on a pending federal lawsuit West Flagler filed against the city over an ordinance that would require the company to seek final approval for the fronton from city boards and the city commission. West Flagler contends that a 2012 opinion by then-zoning administrator Barnaby Min allows the fronton to be built and that the casino operator only has to obtain state permits to open the jai alai and card room facility.

In an earlier ruling for the Braman-Perez lawsuit, Hanzman ruled Min’s opinion had no legal basis, said Grace Mead, a shareholder with Stearns Weaver Miller, which represents the plaintiffs. “The letter West Flagler obtained would have opened up two-thirds of the city to gambling,” Mead said. “It has no legal effect and because of that they don’t have a legal basis to move forward with the Jai Alai facility in Edgewater.”

DeMaria said his client is offering the city the same terms, including waiving all attorney fees and a stipulation that West Flagler will not place slot machines in the proposed fronton and card room. “The same day Hanzman ruled, I resubmitted the settlement agreement to the city,” he said. “If it doesn’t get approved, all bets are off. Mr. Braman and his anti-gambling crusade need to seriously think about what he’s doing to the city. This is going to be a pari mutuel activity, which has been around since 1932.”


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
A photo illustration featuring a rendering of the Edition Residences Edgewater (left), the Belmar Condominium at 419 Northeast 19th Street (middle), and a rendering of Aria Reserve (right) (Getty Images, Google Maps, Melo Group, Two Roads Development, Master Brokers Forum)
South Florida by the numbers: Living on the Edge(water)
South Florida by the numbers: Living on the Edge(water)
From left: Isaac Toledano, Teddy Sagi, Jorge Pérez and Michael Masanoff with a rendering of Transit Village (Related, LinkedIn, Rendering via Arquitectonica)
Pérez and Sagi’s Transit Village in WPB advances
Pérez and Sagi’s Transit Village in WPB advances
Manor Broken Sound at 5400 Broken Sound Boulevard in Boca Raton, with Rockpoint’s Bill Walton, Related Group's Jon Paul Pérez and Jorge Pérez and Lincoln Property Company CEO Tim Byrne (Cushman & Wakefield, Rockpoint, Related Group, Wikipedia, Lincoln Property Group)
Lincoln Property pays $194M for newly built Boca apartments
Lincoln Property pays $194M for newly built Boca apartments
Anand Mahindra and developer Rotem Rosen with 1801 NE 2nd Avenue in Miami (Google Maps, Mahindra, Getty)
Rotem Rosen, Anand Mahindra finally close on $30M Edgewater site
Rotem Rosen, Anand Mahindra finally close on $30M Edgewater site
Two Roads' Reid Boren and Taylor Collins with rendering of the Edition Residences Edgewater (Two Roads Development)
Two Roads launches sales of Edition-branded Edgewater condos
Two Roads launches sales of Edition-branded Edgewater condos
Yizhak Toledano and a rendering of the project at 2261 Northeast 164th Street in Miami beach (Cohen Freedman, YizhakToledano.org)
BH Group: Big investments, big partners and big mystery
BH Group: Big investments, big partners and big mystery
SB Development’s Joseph Stern and Belmar Condominum at 419 Northeast 19th Street (LinkedIn, Google Maps)
SB Development completes bulk condo purchase in Edgewater
SB Development completes bulk condo purchase in Edgewater
Related Group's Jorge Pérez and Jon Paul Pérez; rendering of the Gallery at Marti Park project (CMA Architects, Related Group, Getty)
Jorge Pérez’s Related wants to build apartments in Miami’s Little Havana
Jorge Pérez’s Related wants to build apartments in Miami’s Little Havana
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...