Miami-Dade County wins lawsuit over Coconut Grove Playhouse partial demolition

Judges cited “troubling” emails sent to Miami’s mayor that presumably prejudiced him

Miami /
Apr.April 15, 2021 06:00 PM
The Coconut Grove Playhouse and Miami Mayor Francis Suarez (Phillip Pessar/Flickr, Getty)

The Coconut Grove Playhouse and Miami Mayor Francis Suarez (Phillip Pessar/Flickr, Getty)

A plan to partly demolish and renovate the historic Coconut Grove Playhouse is back in play, after a court struck Miami Mayor Francis Suarez’s veto of the project.

Miami-Dade County wants to build a 300-seat theater that would incorporate elements of the original 1927 auditorium and restore the facade. The playhouse has a city historic designation and is on the National Register of Historic Places.

In its ruling, a circuit court appellate panel cited “troubling” emails between Suarez and several preservationists sent to him before his May 2019 veto. The emails “addressed the justification for and substance” of the veto message and “are presumed to be prejudicial,” violating the county’s due process, Judge Lisa Walsh wrote in the April 7 opinion.

In one email, Coral Gables-based architect Richard Heisenbottle attached a draft veto message. It’s unknown whether Suarez incorporated Heisenbottle’s proposed language as the attachment wasn’t in court filings, Walsh wrote.

Suarez, who had flagged the emails and forwarded them to his attorney, didn’t return a request for comment. Miami City Attorney Victoria Méndez said the city will ask the court to clarify its opinion.

Heisenbottle said it’s “preposterous” the court reopened the door to the playhouse’s auditorium demolition just because a constituent wrote an email to the mayor. “They offer no proof that the mayor, in the formation of his veto, ever referred to the content of my email,” he said.

Heisenbottle called on Miami-Dade Mayor Daniella Levine Cava to drop the lawsuit and for a complete “change in direction.” Levine Cava didn’t return a request for comment. The county’s proposal was initiated under former Miami-Dade County Mayor Carlos Gimenez. The county and Florida International University lease the property from the state.

Heisenbottle has been at the forefront of preservationists’ fight to restore the original sky-blue, Mediterranean Revival playhouse at 3500 Main Highway into what the preservationists call “the Broadway of the South.” The playhouse was designed by Kiehnel and Elliott architecture firm, and Robert Browning Parker renovated and redesigned it in 1955, with a Modern twist. Preservationists view the county’s plan as a development project and not a restoration.

The court ruling is the latest in a saga that dates to 2017 when the county first applied for its project.

City staff at the time – wrongly – signed off on the proposal as the city report was incorrect in saying that only the facades require preservation, Walsh wrote in the ruling. A Miami preservation officer’s report issued in 2005 had deemed the facades as architecturally significant but added that the entire building is historic.

The Miami Historic and Environmental Preservation Board in March 2019 shot down the county’s proposal, but the city commission overrode the historic board’s decision and approved the county’s plan.

Then in May 2019, Suarez vetoed the commission’s approval. The commission failed to overturn his decision, as a supermajority vote is needed to override a veto.

The following June, Miami-Dade filed its petition to the Miami-Dade Circuit Court appellate division to nullify the veto. The appellate division dismissed the county’s lawsuit. But the county then appealed to a higher court, the Third District Court of Appeals, which reversed the lower court’s dismissal.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    John Ruiz with 530 Arvida Parkway
    John Ruiz sells waterfront Gables Estates home for discounted $30M
    John Ruiz sells waterfront Gables Estates home for discounted $30M
    1800 West Indiantown Road in Jupiter, PGIM's Eric Adler with 12503-12681 Miramar Parkway in Miramar and Orion Real Estate Group's  Kevin Sanz with 13605-13619 South Dixie Highway in Pinecrest
    South Florida retail vacancies drop, rents rise in the fourth quarter
    South Florida retail vacancies drop, rents rise in the fourth quarter
    The Development site at 9163-9165 Collins Avenue in Surfside with Fort Partners' Nadim Ashi
    Fort Partners pays $42M for Surfside condo development site
    Fort Partners pays $42M for Surfside condo development site
    From left: Prologis' Hamid Moghadam, MG3 Group’s Marcelo Saiegh, and TA Realty's James Buckingham (Getty, Prologis, MG3 Group, TA Realty)
    South Florida industrial market softens, rents rise again in fourth quarter
    South Florida industrial market softens, rents rise again in fourth quarter
    Alex and Yanina Sapir, the Venetian Islands and the motion
    Alex Sapir secretly attempted to sell Miami Beach home amid divorce, wife alleges
    Alex Sapir secretly attempted to sell Miami Beach home amid divorce, wife alleges
    Palazzo Della Luna at 6800 Fisher Island Drive in Miami Beach
    Palazzo Della Luna closing tops Miami-Dade weekly condo sales
    Palazzo Della Luna closing tops Miami-Dade weekly condo sales
    Raanan Katz with 800 East Hallandale Beach Boulevard
    Raanan Katz’s shopping center allegedly tells neighbor: No parking for you!
    Raanan Katz’s shopping center allegedly tells neighbor: No parking for you!
    (Illustration by The Real Deal with Getty)
    South Florida residential dollar volume falls 50% in December
    South Florida residential dollar volume falls 50% in December
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...