Broker accuses SL Green of stiffing her on $1.4M commission

Lori Shabtai’s lawsuit says she was offered $100K “tip” for Madison Avenue building sales

Lori Shabtai and SL Green CEO Marc Holliday (Getty, SL Green)
Lori Shabtai and SL Green CEO Marc Holliday (Getty, SL Green)

Broker Lori Shabtai claims SL Green shafted her on a $1.4 million commission, instead offering her an “insulting ‘tip’ of $100,000.”

The broker filed a lawsuit detailing the allegations against the big commercial landlord, Crain’s reported.

Read more

SL Green CEO Marc Holliday and the Daily News Building  at 220 East 42nd Street (Google Maps; SL Green)
Commercial
New York
SL Green sues Chetrit over $35M deposit for scuttled Daily News deal
Isaac Zion
Commercial
New York
SL Green’s co-CIO leaving firm
SL Green CEO Marc Holliday, One Madison Avenue and Hines Group CEO Jeffrey Hines (SL Green; Hines via Sanjeev Verma/Hindustan Times via Getty Images)
Commercial
New York
SL Green sells half of One Madison to Hines, NPS of Korea

Shabtai claims she is due the commission from two deals she brokered in 2018 for SL Green at 710 and 712 Madison Avenue with jeweler Graff, a tenant at 710 Madison.

Sign Up for the undefined Newsletter

Graff bought 710 Madison for $66.5 million and entered into a $12.4 million, 25-year ground lease at 712 Madison. Shabtai says she is owed a 2 percent commission for the sale and 1.75 percent for the lease.

Her attorney, David Jaroslawicz, claims that the collapse of SL Green’s unrelated deal to buy the Daily News Building and its plummeting stock is part of the reason why Shabtai wasn’t paid her commission. The company’s share price is less than half of its peak in February, before the pandemic walloped the New York City office market, which is the firm’s focus.

In April, SL Green’s CFO Matthew DiLiberto unveiled what he called its “billion-dollar plan” — amassing a mountain of cash to weather the pandemic.

SL Green did not comment to Crain’s on the lawsuit. [Crain’s] — Erin Hudson

Recommended For You