Success Academy buys Brooklyn yeshiva building for $37M

Sale comes year after Jeff Sutton helped Magen David buy new properties

Charter school buys Brooklyn yeshiva building
Success Academy Charter Schools founder Eva Moskowitz and 7801 Bay Parkway in Brooklyn (X, Google Maps)

A charter school network has bought a Brooklyn building that housed a Jewish high school.

Success Academy Charter Schools paid $37.2 million to Magen David Yeshivah for two properties at 7801 and 7815 Bay Parkway in Gravesend, according to property records.

The sale comes a year after retail mogul Jeff Sutton, who sits on the board at the yeshiva, helped arrange a $14 million deal for the Sephardic school to buy three Gravesend properties for a new high school building.

The yeshiva is developing a new, 81,000-square-foot, $50 million building at the site that is expected to be completed in January 2027, according to PincusCo, which first reported the sale.

Sign Up for the undefined Newsletter

Magen David was founded in 1946 and also runs an elementary school at 2130 McDonald Avenue and an early childhood center at 2170 McDonald Avenue.

Gravesend is the home base of Sutton and many other Syrian Jews who have made their fortunes in New York City’s retail and garment industries.

A representative for Success Academy, Eva Moskowitz’s controversial charter school network,  and the yeshiva’s attorney did not immediately respond to requests for comment. 

Read more

Jeff Sutton with 1905, 1911 and 1915 McDonald Avenue and Magen David Yeshivah
New York
Jeff Sutton arranges $14M deal for Gravesend school
New York
"You can go up one block and get a $1 million discount”: Ocean Parkway teardowns are hot property
New York
The Syrian retail touch
Recommended For You