NYC Rejects Pied-à-Terre Tax Buyer Protections

This story gives you a peek at the content coming to our new platform, TRD Policy Pro. Sign up to get early access here.

Hi, let’s get into today’s news at the intersection of policy and real estate:

The city adopted rules to implement the pied-à-terre tax — without heeding attorneys' calls for buyer protections.
A new City Council bill would boost eligibility for SCRIE and DRIE.
City unveils new code-change guide as builders gear up for a big compliance shift.

In this edition we mention: City Council member Farah Louis, Department of Finance, the Department of Buildings and others.

We Heard

Policy reject: The city’s Department of Finance finalized initial rules for its new pied-à-terre tax on pricey second homes. They come after a contentious July 9 hearing and a flood of feedback, resulting in 12 pages of revised rules. What is perhaps most noteworthy about the new rules is what did not make it in: protections that would have prevented luxury buyers from being on the hook for a past owner’s pied-à-terre tax bill. Because the rules give the DOF six years to audit records and determine whether pied-à-terre taxes are owed, real estate attorneys pushed for an “innocent purchaser” provision to protect buyers from liabilities incurred by prior owners. The agency flatly said no. “DOF declines to make changes in response to these comments,” states the finance department’s memo on the final rules. “State law provides that the surcharge is imposed on a property, rather than a particular owner of property.” If luxury buyers want to protect themselves from being hit with the levy, the agency suggests they structure their transactions to “allocate the risk” onto the seller. In other words, buyers of luxury homes could inherit a retroactive pied-à-terre tax bill — with the city leaving it to buyers’ lawyers to account for the risk at closing. DOF said it will “continue to consider” if changes are needed for buyers down the road.
Benefit boost: Brooklyn City Council member Farah Louis introduced a bill that would make more seniors and people with disabilities eligible for city programs that freeze their rent yet remain popular with landlords because they get a tax credit that makes up the difference. Louis’ bill would build on Albany lawmakers’ expansion of the eligibility threshold for SCRIE and DRIE — the Senior Citizens Rent Increase Exemption and Disability Rent Increase Exemption — in this year’s state budget. The proposal would raise the income cap for households that spend a third of their monthly income on rent to $75,000 from $50,000 and apply the change retroactively to July 1, the start of the city’s fiscal year. The income threshold has not been updated since 2015. “We must protect our low-income residents from being priced out of neighborhoods they call homes for decades,” said Louis in a statement. “This bill addresses the eligibility challenges we face, strengthening housing security for tenants, ultimately lowering tenant turnover for landlords and reducing eviction risk.” But the bill does little to address a bigger challenge facing the program: ensuring eligible tenants know it exists and can navigate its complicated application process. A June 2025 report from the Department of Finance found that roughly 160,000 households were potentially eligible for SCRIE and DRIE, but only about 67,000 received the benefits. That means just 42 percent of eligible households were taking advantage of the program.
Code switch: New York City’s design and construction industry is heading into a major regulatory shift. A pair of bills passed by the City Council in 2026 are set to replace the city’s 1968 building code with the New York City Existing Building Code as of July 17, 2027. The new framework represents a comprehensive shift for how teams approach alterations to existing properties, and will impact everything from early project planning to city filings and construction oversight. With the transition now about a year away, the Department of Buildings has begun releasing monthly newsletters aimed at helping industry professionals better understand the changes and prepare for the new requirements. The first edition was published this month, as part of the city’s ongoing effort to guide the real estate industry through the changes.

Have a tip or feedback? Reach me at caroline.spivack@therealdeal.com.

Bill Tracker

Bill Number	Lead Sponsor(s)	Summary	Committee
Intro. 0978	City Council member Farah Louis	Increases the household income eligibility threshold for the SCRIE and DRIE programs	Committee on Housing and Buildings

The Agenda

The City Council’s zoning subcommittee will meet on Tuesday at 11 a.m. to discuss multiple land use items. More details here.

The city’s Commission on Government Efficiency will hold its final meeting on Thursday at 5 p.m., where it will discuss and vote on putting several ballot measures before voters in November, including on permitting reform for construction-related approvals. More details here.

The Catch-Up

The fallout from last week’s structural failure at the former Pfizer building has given union leaders fresh ammunition in their push for more project labor agreements, reports The Real Deal’s Ben Miller.

A West Harlem rental building recently listed for $57,000 per unit — comparable to the price of a luxury SUV, illustrating the sharp decline in market value for rent-stabilized properties, writes TRD columnist Erik Engquist.

City Comptroller Mark Levine broke with tenant advocates over the weekend, blaming rent regulations for keeping apartments off the market and deepening the housing crisis, reports the New York Post.

For voters ages 18 to 34, housing is the top political issue — outranking food prices, protecting democracy and immigration — according to a CNBC survey.

The Kicker
“The most protected tenant is an organized tenant,” said Cea Weaver, director of the Mayor’s Office to Protect Tenants on the city’s new “Talk to Tenants” door-to-door organizing campaign.