Montauk trailer listing eyes record — even with a price cut

Listing asks $4.4M for 2K sf home in possible peak

Montauk Shores Trailer Listing Eyes Record
200 Edgewater Drive Unit 200 in Montauk NY (Google Maps)

A trailer home in Montauk had its listing price cut by $600,000 and still might wind up as the most expensive sale of its kind.

A 2,150-square-foot property in the luxury Montauk Shores trailer park is on the market for $4.4 million, the New York Post reported. Unit #200 at 200 Edgewater Drive in the East End town previously listed for $5 million in the spring. If it sells for its listing price, it would set a record for trailer home sales in Montauk Shores, though the price per square foot of $2,046 wouldn’t be a record.

The modular home has two bedrooms and two bathrooms, located steps from the famed Ditch Plains surfing spot. Constructed eight years ago, the home also has a wraparound deck, an outdoor shower, central air inside, an open layout and a loft.

Montauk Shores Trailer Listing Eyes Record
Keller Williams agent Mackenzie Burniche (Keller Williams)

Keller Williams Realty Landmark’s Mackenzie Burniche has the listing.

Sign Up for the undefined Newsletter

The Montauk Shores record was smashed in February when a 800-square-foot trailer sold off-market for $3.75 million, or $5,000 per square foot. The previous record was less than half of that.

Approximately a dozen homes in Montauk Shores have sold in the last couple of years, ranging in price from $675,000 to $1.4 million. While seven-figure deals in the community were once unheard of, the premium of living within a hop and a skip of the ocean has sent prices soaring, especially as wealthy homeowners seek a different lifestyle.

Among the celebrities and business figures to put down roots in Montauk Shores are Jimmy Buffett (who won a bidding war for his trailer), film producer Karen Lauder, billionaire investor Daniel Loeb and Energy Brands co-founder Darius Bikoff.

The community, which sits on a bluff overlooking the Atlantic Ocean, features amenities including swimming pools, a rec center, a basketball court and a playground.

Holden Walter-Warner

Read more