Eviction moratorium case edges closer to Supreme Court

Landlord trade group’s petition gets attention of at least one justice

Los Angeles /
Jan.January 11, 2022 04:12 PM
Dan Yukelson of AAGLA (Optimum Seismic)
Dan Yukelson of AAGLA (Optimum Seismic)

A landlord group’s challenge to the City of Los Angeles’s long-running — and controversial — eviction moratorium has moved a step closer to a hearing before the Supreme Court.

The development came when the court requested a response in the case from the City of Los Angeles. The odds of an eventual hearing before the nation’s top court remain long, but the request on January 10 means that the challenge from the Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles (AAGLA) is still alive — and that at least one justice was interested in the case.

“Every week they kick like a couple dozen of these [petitions] without a response, so the fact that someone on the court is interested is definitely a positive sign,” said Jared McClain, a lawyer with the New Civil Liberties Association, a legal advocacy group that is supporting AAGLA’s challenge.

Numerous amicus briefs that were filed in support of AAGLA, McClain added, likely helped put the challenge on the justices’ radar.

“It showed the court that there’s interest in the community about this case, and probably got someone’s attention on the court,” he said.

A lawyer working on the case for the City Attorney’s office declined to comment, referring The Real Deal to an office representative. The representative also declined to comment.

A lawyer representing AAGLA did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The Supreme Court’s action was the latest twist in what’s become a protracted, high-stakes legal battle that also illuminates a stark line cutting through everyday life and the economy. Many renters as well as landlords have grown increasingly adamant from opposite viewpoints of the eviction moratorium as the pandemic approaches its third year.

“It is, but for the shooting, a war in every real sense,” one district judge noted as part of an opinion related to AAGLA’s challenge. “Hundreds of thousands of tenants pitted against tens of thousands of landlords — that is the tragedy that brings us here.”

The City of L.A. issued its first eviction moratorium, and a freeze on rent hikes, in March of 2020, as a response to the sudden economic collapse brought by the early effects of Covid-19 and related shutdowns. The measures were intended to stave off another potential crisis: tens or hundreds of thousands of newly unemployed renters facing homelessness. But the tenant-centered protections meant that area landlords also lost income, and many small property owners have faced increasing economic hardship.

“I don’t think legislators understand this side of the coin,” Irma Vargas of RST & Associates, a management firm that works with small property owners, said last summer. “They all think landlords are these fat cats that can withstand, and they can’t.”

While federal and state eviction moratoriums have recently expired, the City of L.A.’s — which is tied to a local emergency order and has the strong support of local politicians, including Mayor Eric Garcetti — remains in place.

AAGLA filed its first legal challenge to the ordinance in federal district court in 2020. The group lost that case last August, when a federal appeals court also denied the challenge.

But the case has found some broader support within the real estate community and certain legal circles. The New Civil Liberties Alliance, a Washington, D.C.-based advocacy group, filed an amicus brief supporting the Supreme Court challenge in late December; the California Apartment Association, California Association of Realtors and the Foundation for Moral Law, a rightwing, Alabama-based legal nonprofit, have also filed amicus briefs in support.

Two tenant rights groups — the Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment Action and Strategic Actions for a Just Economy (SAJE) — are supporting the City of Los Angeles.

AAGLA’s legal challenge relates to the U.S. Constitution’s Contract Clause, which concerns private contracts and the limits of governmental interference. The landlord group is arguing the City of L.A.’s eviction moratorium, which permits tenants to forestall previously agreed upon rent payments, amounts to an illegal intervention; a potential Supreme Court hearing on the case, or a similar one, could have major ramifications for both the real estate industry and broader economy.

The court will likely decide in March whether or not to hear AAGLA’s challenge.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    San Jose, Parking
    San Jose mulls removing parking requirements for new developments
    San Jose mulls removing parking requirements for new developments
    Illustration of an apartment and hand holding a penny
    SF, SJ lone markets in U.S. to lag pre-pandemic mark on resi rents
    SF, SJ lone markets in U.S. to lag pre-pandemic mark on resi rents
    Bell Partners president and ceo Lili F. Dunn with renderings of Cadence Apartments at 400 Cypress Avenue in South San Francisco (Chet Frohlich, Bell Partners Inc.)
    Builder sells 260-unit apartment complex in South San Francisco
    Builder sells 260-unit apartment complex in South San Francisco
    A photo illustration of 625 Scott Street (Allison Chapleau, iStock)
    “Could it be any more trophy?”: Largest apartment building on the market in SF lists for $20M
    “Could it be any more trophy?”: Largest apartment building on the market in SF lists for $20M
    Strada Investment Group co-founder Jesse Blout with Trammel Crow ceo Mike Lafitte and renderings of the redevelopment of piers 30-32, Lot 330, Embarcadero in San Francisco (Trammel Crow, StradaSF, Steelblue for Strada Investment Group)
    Developers buck regulatory headwinds on $1.2B plan to redevelop SF piers
    Developers buck regulatory headwinds on $1.2B plan to redevelop SF piers
    A photo illustration depicting the fluctuation of the San Francisco rental market (iStock, Apartment List)
    San Francisco rentals make gains, still last market lagging behind pre-pandemic numbers
    San Francisco rentals make gains, still last market lagging behind pre-pandemic numbers
    The Pacific Companies' Caleb Roope (The Pacific Companies, iStock)
    $130M in bond financing for Bay Area affordable multifamily projects
    $130M in bond financing for Bay Area affordable multifamily projects
    CityMark's Daniel Walsh (LinkedIn, Apartments.com)
    Cleveland investor gets 108-unit East Bay complex
    Cleveland investor gets 108-unit East Bay complex
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...