The drama behind Jay Bialsky’s $25M listing in Sag Harbor

How the Hamptons developer ended up with three sprawling waterfront homes

Tri-State /
Jun.June 14, 2021 08:00 AM
 Jay Bialsky and 2 West Water Street in Sag Harbor (Getty, renderings via Bespoke Real Estate)

Jay Bialsky and 2 West Water Street in Sag Harbor (Getty, renderings via Bespoke Real Estate)

It seems that Jay Bialsky has played his cards right in Sag Harbor.

The Hamptons developer’s Residence B at 2 West Water Street has hit the market, asking nearly $25 million, a year before the unit is expected to be finished. It will follow residence A, which will be Bialsky’s home after its completion in November, and residence C, scheduled to be ready in May.

The homes boast curated interiors, expansive terraces and two private boat slips each.

“Four years ago, I owned an ugly white building,” Bialsky said. “Now you have a whole revitalization of the waterfront in Sag Harbor.”

But getting to this point has not been easy.

The “ugly white building” was a 14-unit co-op complex with some businesses on the first floor. Owner Bruce Davis — the founder of 1-800-Lawyers — put it on the market in 2011 for $12 million, but found no takers. After five years of price cuts, Greystone purchased the property for $4.94 million.

Greystone had grand plans to build 11 to 13 units, designed by architect Robert Stern. But the Sag Harbor Village Zoning Board of Appeals struck that down, deeming the proposed condos too massive and of little benefit to the community.

In the face of resistance, Greystone sold the parcels to Bialsky, who came up with the three-apartment plan but encountered similar issues. The board put pressure on Bialsky to downsize his project after he proposed building 11 feet higher and 15 feet closer to the street than allowed.

But within 12 months, Bialsky received approval for the tallest variances Sag Harbor had granted in 100 years.

It did not hurt his chances that in mid-2019 Bialsky orchestrated the sale of his parcel next door — at 1,3, 5 Ferry Road — to Southampton for $10.5 million. The land will become the John Steinbeck Waterfront Park. (The legendary writer had a retreat in Sag Harbor that recently hit the market.)

“I could’ve built over 60,000 square feet,” Bialsky said. “[But] I felt it was the right thing to do, the path of least resistance. I thought it was a win-win for both the villages of Sag Harbor and me as developer.”

Now, it’s possible to walk from the east side of Long Wharf along the boardwalk, onto the beach, through John Steinbeck Waterfront Park and up to 2 West Water Street. Bespoke, a brokerage focused on homes asking more than $10 million, has the listing for residence B.

Another potential action, from the Village of Sag Harbor, could make the project even more valuable.

Sag Harbor is reviewing zoning codes to preserve the “eclectic qualities” of the waterfront, according to the village’s website. Bialsky says it will likely prevent more buildings the size of his from being constructed, which would, in theory, ensure his properties remain the only local ones of their kind.

“Now, to me, that’s wonderful,” Bialsky said.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Anthony "Fat Tony" Salerno and the Rhinebeck horse farm (Hudson Modern, Getty)
    Rhinebeck farm once owned by mob boss lists for $1.5M
    Rhinebeck farm once owned by mob boss lists for $1.5M
    Long Island Board of Realtor's Tessa Hultz (LIRealtor.com, HomeForAllOfUs.org, iStock)
    How not to discriminate: Long Island Realtors launch fair housing effort
    How not to discriminate: Long Island Realtors launch fair housing effort
    Saunders & Associates' Andrew Saunders and Fortune International Group's Edgardo Defortuna (Saunders & Associates, Fortune International Group, iStock)
    Saunders & Associates, Fortune International launch referral program
    Saunders & Associates, Fortune International launch referral program
    Julia Koch and 840 Meadow Lane in Southampton (Getty Images, Tim Davis/Corcoran)
    Julia Koch revealed as buyer of dated $70M Southampton estate
    Julia Koch revealed as buyer of dated $70M Southampton estate
    Friends of Bay Street Chairman Adam Potter and rendering of new affordable housing and commercial space (LinkedIn, BHC Architects, Illustration by Kevin Cifuentes for The Real Deal)
    Affordable housing project proposed for Sag Harbor
    Affordable housing project proposed for Sag Harbor
    Sophocles Zoullas and 275 Ox Pasture Road in Southampton (Getty Images, Harald Grant Real Estate, iStock)
    ‘Tenacre’ estate is only 3 acres, but lists for $25M
    ‘Tenacre’ estate is only 3 acres, but lists for $25M
    Mariano Rivera and 1 Brook View Lane in Rye (Getty Images, Compass, iStock/Photo Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
    Exit Sandman: Mariano Rivera closes sale of Rye mansion for $2M loss
    Exit Sandman: Mariano Rivera closes sale of Rye mansion for $2M loss
    95 Conant Valley Road, Pound Ridge (Zillow)
    Pound Ridge home sells for more than twice its ask after bidding frenzy
    Pound Ridge home sells for more than twice its ask after bidding frenzy
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...