Plaza hotel’s Citi Bike suit may have legs

Plaintiff’s argument focused on bike-share rack’s aesthetic impact

TRD New York /
Apr.April 22, 2014 06:35 PM

The same Manhattan judge who threw out two lawsuits angling to remove Citi Bike racks may view a complaint from the tony Plaza Hotel in a different light.

“This one actually has different arguments — a different approach from the other two,” Justice Cynthia Kern said before a proceeding in the Plaza’s 2013 suit, according to the New York Post. “Clearly I’ve been going a certain way with the last two,” she added.

The first case, she explained, was tossed because it claimed the rack, set upon a sliver of green space in Soho, constituted improper park use. The second, brought by a Greenwich Village co-op Cambridge House at 175 West 13th Street, argued that the bike-share violated Department of Transportation rules with its driving lane location.

This time, the argument is that the 147-foot rack is an eyesore. Steven Orel, the Plaza’s attorney, also said the city violated the law because it did not perform a mandatory environmental review on the aesthetic impact of the rack before placing it between West 58th and 59th streets.

Citi Bank, the bike share sponsor and a defendant in the case, did not appear for oral arguments, the Post reported. [NYP]Julie Strickland


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
The Plaza Hotel, Sofitel New York at 45 West 44th Street and Le Bernardin at 155 West 51st Street (Credit: Yarl via Wikipedia Commons, Sofitel and Le Bernadin)

Mass layoffs claim jobs at the Plaza, Sofitel and Le Bernardin

Mass layoffs claim jobs at the Plaza, Sofitel and Le Bernardin
Plaza Hotel managing director George Cozonis with the Plaza Hotel at 768 5th Avenue (Credit: Cozonis by Fernanda Calfat/Getty Images)

The Plaza shuts down and lays off 251

The Plaza shuts down and lays off 251
1 Central Park South, 1007/1009 and Valery Kogan (inset)

Opulent Plaza Hotel unit listed for $45M

Opulent Plaza Hotel unit listed for $45M
The Plaza’s many lives: How moguls, labor fights and a changing city shaped an icon

The Plaza’s many lives: How moguls, labor fights and a changing city shaped an icon

The Plaza’s many lives: How moguls, labor fights and a changing city shaped an icon
Plaza PH buyer spends $29M to expand aerie

Plaza PH buyer spends $29M to expand aerie

Plaza PH buyer spends $29M to expand aerie
How the Plaza was won: A look at Subrata Roy’s path to selling the landmark hotel

How the Plaza was won: A look at Subrata Roy’s path to selling the landmark hotel

How the Plaza was won: A look at Subrata Roy’s path to selling the landmark hotel
How the Plaza was won: A look at Subrata Roy’s path to selling the landmark hotel

How the Plaza was won: A look at Subrata Roy’s path to selling the landmark hotel

How the Plaza was won: A look at Subrata Roy’s path to selling the landmark hotel
Qatari group closes on $600M purchase of Plaza Hotel

Qatari group closes on $600M purchase of Plaza Hotel

Qatari group closes on $600M purchase of Plaza Hotel
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...