Fairstead, Blackstone testing the market for Caiola portfolio sale: sources

Partners bought 24-building package for $690M in September

TRD New York /
Mar.March 11, 2016 03:20 PM

Fairstead Capital and the Blackstone Group are exploring their options to sell the massive 24-building Caiola portfolio they purchased for $690 million in September, according to sources as well as documents reviewed by The Real Deal.

At least two brokerages have been testing the market for the 800,000-square-foot, 979-unit market-rate rental portfolio, likely to be sold in tranches. The owners are looking to see if the portfolio could fetch prices in the vicinity of $1,000 per square foot, which would mean an overall value of $800 million, sources familiar with the matter said.

Fairstead and Blackstone, which have both described their multifamily investments as long-term plays, have not retained an exclusive agent to market it in an official capacity.

A representative for Blackstone declined to comment, as did Fairstead.

The Caiola family acquired, and in many instances, developed the buildings in the portfolio over more than 30 years. After patriarch Benny Caiola died in 2010, his children took on the task of determining the fate of the buildings, which were largely scattered through the Upper East Side, Murray Hill and Chelsea. The addresses include 250 West 19th Street, 345 West 30th Street, 449-451 East 83rd Street and 341-343 East 62nd Street.

In January 2015, Joseph Sitt’s Thor Equities signed a soft contract for $800 million, but later backed out. Then, in May, Fairstead brought on Blackstone as its partner and, by September, the duo closed on the purchase for $690 million. Maryland-based Annaly Capital Management provided a $592 million acquisition loan.

Related Article

65 East 55th Street and EQ Office CEO Lisa Picard (Credit: Park Avenue Tower and VTS)

Blackstone looks to sell Park Ave Tower for more than $800M

(Illustration by Tim Peacock)

The e-commerce industrial revolution

Blackstone president Jonathan Gray and 145-07 156th Street in Queens (Credit: Getty Images and Google Maps)

Fresh off $18B industrial buy, Blackstone in talks for collection of warehouses near JFK

Blackstone is already selling pieces of the $18B GLP industrial portfolio

Blackstone’s Q2 earnings decline as real estate segment tumbles

Blackstone CEO Jonathan Gray and Stuy Town (Credit: Getty Images and Wikipedia)

Rent-regulation laws prompt Blackstone to halt improvements at Stuy Town

Blackstone-backed mortgage lender Stearns files for bankruptcy

266 East 78th Street

Here’s what the $10M-$20M NYC investment sales market looked like last week