Stabilized Bronx tenants challenge $5.5M in rent increases

Finkelstein Timberger East Real Estate exploited holes in MCI: organizers

New York /
Nov.November 22, 2016 12:30 PM

A Bronx landlord has been taking advantage of a “loophole” in what’s known as Major Capital Investments to spike rents in rent-stabilized apartments, according to tenant organizers.

Tenants in four buildings controlled by Finkelstein Timberger East Real Estate, which owns close to 100 buildings in the Bronx, are challenging a collective $5.5 million in MCI increases. Tenants say the landlord made unnecessary improvements to their apartments, and some are seeing their rent increase by more than 30 percent, the Village Voice reported.

A landlord can raise rents of rent stabilized apartments if they’re able to prove that they’ve made building-wide improvements, known as major capital investments, such as improving the roof, the heating on site, or elevators.

The rent increases are permanent, and while MCIs are often legitimate, critics say they can be easily exploited for the purpose of pricing out rent-stabilized tenants. MCI rent increases are approved by the Department of Homes and Community Renewal.

The tenant organizers say Finkelstein’s business model relies heavily on exploiting the holes in MCI regulations. Normally, landlords must first receive permission from rent-stabilized tenants to renovate or upgrade their apartments, known as Individual Apartment Improvements, in exchange for a rent increase. However, under MCI, if a landlord makes improvements for all the tenants in the building, they can bypass that step.

A tenant at Finkelstein’s 901 Walton Avenue in the Bronx said that as soon as the firm bought the building in February 2014, they immediately sent a letter saying they would be rehabbing the bathrooms, and kitchens, elevator and roof. “None of us asked for it,” the tenant told the Village Voice. “We were fine with what we had.” His rent will increase from $754 to just over $1000 a month.

Steven Finkelstein, the firm’s head, says the renovations are “essential” and that he renovates the whole building at a time to take advantage of the city’s J51 program, which gives owners tax abatements for renovating rent-stabilized apartments.

In another case involving renovations, although not MCIs, A&E Real Estate TRData LogoTINY, one of the city’s biggest landlords, is being sued by tenants across multiple buildings, for allegedly overstating the cost of renovations in their building to increase rent and destabilize apartments. In that case, A&E made the improvements as individual apartment improvements (IAIs). The firm, led by Douglas Eisenberg, has denied any wrongdoing and maintains that most of the claims precede its ownership of the properties.  [Village Voice]Chava Gourarie 


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
1065-1075 Gerard Avenue in the Bronx 
Prana pays Related $36M in Bronx multifamily play
Prana pays Related $36M in Bronx multifamily play
448 East 143rd Street in the Bronx (Credit: Google Maps)
Private developer’s NYCHA project in Mott Haven lands $79M in financing
Private developer’s NYCHA project in Mott Haven lands $79M in financing
1159 and 1184 River Avenue with Maddd Equities' Jorge Madruga (left) and Joy Construction's Eli Weiss (right) (Credit: Google Maps)
Maddd Equities, Joy Construction score $64M for massive Bronx project
Maddd Equities, Joy Construction score $64M for massive Bronx project
A photo illustration of Peter Fine and 1959 Jerome Avenue (Getty, Google Maps)
Peter Fine to build 333 units in the Bronx
Peter Fine to build 333 units in the Bronx
 494 Manhattan Avenue in Greenpoint (Google Maps, Getty)
Stakes in Brooklyn apartments sell for $37M, leading midsize i-sales
Stakes in Brooklyn apartments sell for $37M, leading midsize i-sales
A photo illustration of Mayor of New York City Eric Adams (Getty)
Adams’ first rezoning plan centers on 46-block stretch of the Bronx
Adams’ first rezoning plan centers on 46-block stretch of the Bronx
A photo illustration of Mayor of New York City Eric Adams (Getty)
Eric Adams proposes 6K new units near Bronx commuter stations
Eric Adams proposes 6K new units near Bronx commuter stations
From left: Joseph Strasburg, Jay Martin, and Jim Whelan (Getty)
Real estate’s wish list: Industry’s priorities for 2023
Real estate’s wish list: Industry’s priorities for 2023
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...