Both landlords claim managing rights to the owning entity of the building at 97 Second Avenue, which was foreclosed on earlier this year.
Toledano lost control of the property when he defaulted on a $2 million loan from Brian Lefkowitz’s Lefko Funding, for which it served as collateral.
In April, Lefkowtiz sold the membership interest in the owning entity, 97 2nd LLC, for $9.1 million to an LLC he controlled. Then, in July, Shah acquired a $9.5 million note on the property from Signature Bank.
At this point, the stories diverge. According to Shah, and documents filed with the city, Lefkowitz transferred the ownership to Shah, putting him in control of the property. According to Toledano, Lefkowitz had given him managing rights for a 75-day period beginning in June, until the sale was finalized. Shah denies knowing of any such agreement until recently, and challenges its validity.
In August, during the 75-day period, Toledano filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection on the property and tried to procure a buyer. According to court documents filed by Shah, Toledano also used that time to threaten and extort him. Toledano threatened to instruct the tenants to withhold rent, according to the documents, and told Shah, “I will bury you, literally. I will bury this building and make sure of it.”
Earlier this week, Shah filed a to dismiss the bankruptcy case, claiming that Toledano had no rights to the property at the time he filed it.
In response to the motion to dismiss, Toledano filed the new complaint claiming that Shah bought the property knowing that Toledano was challenging the the Lefkowitz foreclosure, and that the transfer to Shah should be voided.
Toledano declined to comment for this story. A spokesperson for Shah said that Toledano had been foreclosed on by his own lender and is “merely engaging in judicial harassment.”
The 27-year-old landlord is awaiting approval for the sale of the deeds of 15 distressed East Village properties to lender Madison Realty Capital, which recently replaced him as property manager on the buildings.