The Real Deal New York

Rental incentives are no longer stopping the fall of rents

Manhattan’s September vacancy rate was the highest it’s been all year
By Miriam Hall | October 12, 2017 07:30AM

Clockwise from bottom left: 455 West 23rd Street #5B, 795 Fifth Avenue #39, 27-19 44th Dr #17E, 577 Baltic Street #7D

Rental incentives — which landlords have been using all year to fend off increasing vacancy rates and dipping rents — are no longer working as they once were.

Last month, the Manhattan vacancy rate hit 2.6 percent, the highest level it’s been all year, according to the monthly report from Douglas Elliman. The median net effective rent slipped slightly to $3,334, while the share of new leases with concessions hit 27 percent, up from 15 percent last year.

“The market is drifting lower, and the next tool for landlords is going to be cutting prices,” said Jonathan Miller, the CEO of appraisal firm Miller Samuel and author of the report. “Concession aren’t going to go away [but] you won’t see them rise.”

The median rental price of a Manhattan studio was $2,600 a month in September, according to the report, while the luxury median price — which represents the top 10 percent of the market — hit $8,200. The median price for a doorman building unit was $3,875, while the non-doorman price hit $2,950. Overall, the days on market was 43 and the listing discount was nearly 3 percent.

In Brooklyn, the net effective median rent fell by 6 percent to hit $2,757 in September. That decline is largest drop since March 2015, according to the report. As is the case in Manhattan, concessions are no longer keeping sliding rents at bay.

“We’ve reached the point where we are going to see more aggressive declines in face rents, just to get it in sync with the large amount of supply,” Miller said. Concessions were part of 20 percent of all new leases in the quarter. The median luxury rental price was $5,500, while the median for a studio was $2,510, according to the report. Days on market was 41 and listing inventory was at 2,467.

“Price-sensitive tenants are comparison shopping like never before,” said Gary Malin, president of Citi Habitats. “Throughout the course of 2017, 15,000 new rental units will have come online in Manhattan and Brooklyn, so renters have plenty of choice.”

In Queens, Miller predicts that there will be more discounts, rather than concessions, ahead. The median net effective price there hit $2,717. Listing inventory was at 516, an 11 percent year-over-year increase. Leases with concessions made up 43 percent of the market, a figure that is driven by the fact that 38 percent of the rentals on the market are new development.