New York takes aim at apartment bans

State bill would allow up to four units on lots, ban exclusionary policies

Tri-State /
Dec.December 10, 2021 04:19 PM
State Senator Brad Hoylman (Getty, iStock)

State Senator Brad Hoylman (Getty, iStock)

The movement to ban single-family zoning has come to New York.

State Sen. Brad Hoylman introduced a bill this week that would allow multifamily construction on almost all residential lots, eliminate parking requirements in cities and villages, and stop larger localities from requiring large lot sizes for homes.

The legislation would prohibit cities and villages from setting minimum lot sizes larger than 1,200 square feet. It would also bar them from requiring off-street parking.

In cities, landowners could build four-family dwellings on any residential lot, or up to six-family buildings within a quarter mile of a train station. In villages, builders could construct duplexes on any residential lot or six-family dwellings near transit stations.

The bill also addresses towns, setting a maximum lot size of 20,000 square feet, or 5,000 square feet if the parcel has access to sewer or water infrastructure.

“We need to end the policy of exclusionary zoning that disadvantages lower- and middle-income New Yorkers,” said Hoylman. “The affordability crisis is best addressed statewide.”

“It starts the conversation, and it starts it with a bang.”

Noah Kazis, Furman Center

The Manhattan Democrat cited a study by the Furman Center which found that New York has some of the most exclusionary zoning in the country, particularly in the suburban enclaves of Westchester and Long Island.

“The results of these policies are clear: a state with fewer homes, higher rents, higher levels of segregation, higher carbon emissions, and a slower economy,” wrote Hoylman.

Noah Kazis, a legal fellow at the Furman Center and the author of the report, says the paper was meant to encourage New York politicians to take the problem of exclusionary zoning as seriously as some counterparts in similar states have.

“I’m really heartened to see this legislation come out because it starts that conversation, and it starts it with a bang,” Kazis said.

In New York, as in nearly every state, the state government leaves zoning to localities. But Connecticut, Massachusetts and California have passed laws to spur increased density in suburbs in recent years.

In California, where nearly two-thirds of all homes are single-family dwellings, lawmakers recently allowed owners of single-family lots to build up to four units on them. The state also passed a bill encouraging higher density near transit hubs.

If Hoylman’s bill gains any traction in Albany, it would face withering pushback from suburban, exurban and rural areas, where apartment projects in single-family areas are usually opposed by local residents.

In the early 1970s, the last time New York tried to integrate its suburbs through zoning reform, the bureaucrat running the program received death threats. Gov. Nelson Rockefeller’s plan was eventually repealed. And, while rezoning can draw bipartisan support, it opponents also tend to come from both sides of the aisle, united by a common desire to prevent change.

Hoylman himself objected to the Soho/Noho upzoning, which was approved this week. Last year he called the plan “the Amy Coney Barrett of rezoning proposals” because it would be decided in the final months of the de Blasio administration. He also said it would allow large buildings that would change the character of the area, which is exactly what critics of his statewide bill will say if it ever gets to a hearing.

But urban planners and advocates of affordable housing are huge fans of allowing multiple dwellings on what are now single-family lots. “These common-sense reforms are incredibly popular,” Hoylman said. “My office inbox is full of New Yorkers thanking me for introducing this bill.”





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    100 Eleventh Avenue (iStock, Rhododendrites/CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons, Illustration by Kevin Cifuentes for The Real Deal)
    Lower-end listings dominate Manhattan’s luxury deals
    Lower-end listings dominate Manhattan’s luxury deals
    Wildfire, Houses
    One in five homes facing wildfire risk, report says
    One in five homes facing wildfire risk, report says
    (Top) 1580 Meadow Lane in Southampton NY and (Bottom) 2056 Montauk Highway in Amagansett NY (Zillow)
    A tale of two oceanfront Hamptons homes
    A tale of two oceanfront Hamptons homes
    Town of East Hampton supervisor Peter Van Scoyoc and Blade's Rob Wiesenthal with East Hampton Airport (East Hampton, Wikipedia)
    East Hampton Airport closure at hand, except…
    East Hampton Airport closure at hand, except…
    More and more homebuyers and investors are coming to the negotiating table with cash in hand. (iStock)
    In cities, “starter homes” getting more difficult to find
    In cities, “starter homes” getting more difficult to find
    A photo illustration of city developers and preservationists arm wrestling (iStock)
    Preservationists and developers duel upstate. Wanna guess who’s winning?
    Preservationists and developers duel upstate. Wanna guess who’s winning?
    John Steinbeck and his Sag Harbor cottage. (Getty)
    John Steinbeck’s Sag Harbor home could become retreat for writers
    John Steinbeck’s Sag Harbor home could become retreat for writers
    Doctor Tom Frist with 1304 Chickering Road (Eagledj CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons, Redfin, iStock)
    Nashville mansion asks $50M, highest in Tennessee history
    Nashville mansion asks $50M, highest in Tennessee history
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...