Black mortgage applicants’ rejection disparity surges

84% disparity cited as homeownership rate falls for minorities

New York /
Jan.January 19, 2022 08:45 AM

(iStock/Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)

Black applicants are being denied mortgages at a significantly higher rate than white ones — and the gap has widened during the pandemic, a study found.

A Zillow analysis of data from the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act revealed the rejection rate was 84 percent higher for Black applicants than white counterparts in 2020. That’s 10 percentage points higher than it was the year before.

Overall, 19.8 percent Black applicants were denied a mortgage in 2020, versus 10.7 percent of white applicants.

Mississippi, by some measures the poorest state in the U.S., had the highest rejection rate for Black applicants: 31 percent.

“Homeowners have seen a plethora of housing gains during the pandemic, but the growing disparity between Black and white homeownership rates and home values paints the picture of who those winners actually are,” said Zillow economist Nicole Bachaud.

Insufficient credit is one of the main explanations for the denials of Black applicants. According to Zillow, more than 6 percent of Black applicants were denied for that reason. It was the cause of 37 percent of their rejections.

Traditional financial services are less prevalent in Black communities, leading some borrowers to use costly services like payday loans, which are difficult to repay and thus can damage credit scores. In 2019, research showed about one in seven Black households were unbanked, making it harder to save for a substantial down payment. Larger down payments improve the odds of getting a mortgage.

Another issue is that Black-owned homes are worth about 17 percent less than the typical American home. Disparities in appraisals result in less home equity and higher loan-to-value ratios, which increase the chances of rejection.

Homes in predominantly Black communities often have higher property taxes, measured against their value. The unequal impact of the pandemic on incomes was another factor.

Obtaining a mortgage is vital for most would-be homeowners. Homeownership fosters wealth accumulation and provides other economic and community benefits, so difficulty obtaining a mortgage can have a negative and long-term impact on a family.

The rate of Black homeownership in the United States is 44 percent, an improvement from 40.6 percent in 2019’s second quarter but below a 49.7 percent peak in 2004. But the gains of the 2000s proved illusory, as the bursting of the housing bubble wiped out billions of dollars in Black owners’ home equity.

Solutions to close the gap are emerging, such as targeted policies to get Black Americans into homeownership. Government lenders Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae have started allowing rental payments to count towards credit history, which could help more Black renters qualify for mortgages.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    L-R: Douglas Elliman CEO Scott Durkin, Serhant CEO Ryan Serhant, Brown Harris Stevens CEO Bess Freedman, The Real Deal's Hiten Samtani (Photos by Paul Dilakian)
    Top resi execs talk brand building, tech and politics at TRD NYC event
    Top resi execs talk brand building, tech and politics at TRD NYC event
    Southampton Village mayor Jesse Warren (Getty Images, iStock, Illustration by Kevin Cifuentes for The Real Deal)
    Southampton Village allows owners to collect summer’s rent upfront
    Southampton Village allows owners to collect summer’s rent upfront
    Zillow economist Nicole Bichaud (Zillow, iStock)
    Where have home values grown more, suburbs or cities? The answer may surprise you
    Where have home values grown more, suburbs or cities? The answer may surprise you
    Clockwise from top left: Eric and Bridget Elkin, Diane Mollica, Liz and Lisa Gillooly and Sarah Frigo (Compass)
    Compass aims to grow its North Fork agent count fivefold
    Compass aims to grow its North Fork agent count fivefold
    Related CEO Jeff Blau and 455 Tenth Avenue (Chris Martin, Google Maps, iStock)
    Related launches lodging for executives’ hybrid work
    Related launches lodging for executives’ hybrid work
    Matt Lauer with 26, 28 & 32 Actors Colony Rd (Getty, Susan Breitenbach)
    Matt Lauer finds buyer for languishing Hamptons estate
    Matt Lauer finds buyer for languishing Hamptons estate
    Barbara Russo, Danielle Englebardt, and Oren and Tal Alexander (Getty, iStock BFA)
    Ranking the top residential brokers on the Upper East Side
    Ranking the top residential brokers on the Upper East Side
    From left: PropTech's Thomas Hennessy and Joseph Beck; Appreciate's Chris Laurence (Appreciate, LinkedIn/Tom Hennessy, LinkedIn/Joseph Beck, iStock)
    Single-family rental platform Appreciate to go public in SPAC deal
    Single-family rental platform Appreciate to go public in SPAC deal
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...