EB-5 investors will get $50M back in tower project settlement

Symmetry Property will return $550K to each of 89 Chinese investors over stalled River North mixed-use development

Chicago /
Dec.December 07, 2020 04:00 PM
Symmetry's managing partner Jeffrey Laytin and rendering of the proposed tower project (Linkedin, Symmetry Property Development)

Symmetry’s managing partner Jeffrey Laytin and rendering of the proposed tower project (Linkedin, Symmetry Property Development)

Over the years, numerous EB-5 investors from China have sued developers and intermediaries in the U.S. over stalled real estate projects in which the plaintiffs alleged they received zero return on investment. Court victories accompanied by financial compensation have been rare.

But dozens of EB-5 investors who have been battling a developer over a Chicago mixed-use tower project will now be getting their money back.

Symmetry Property Development has agreed to return nearly $50 million to Chinese investors for its unbuilt 60-story River North tower, according to Crain’s. In doing so, the New York-based developer settles the two-year long legal fight.

Symmetry has been at odds with its investors, along with lenders, residents and the city since it unveiled the condominium-and-hotel Carillon tower plan in 2017. Two years later and with the project still undeveloped, the EB-5 investors demanded their money back. The tower plans included 246 condo units, 120 timeshare units, 216 hotel rooms and 30,000 square feet of retail space, Crain’s reported.

Under the proposed settlement, 89 Chinese citizens are entitled to receive $550,000 each, the amount invested through the U.S. visa program, according to Crain’s. The total adds up to about $49 million. A federal judge has agreed to the settlement.

The matter, however, does not put an end to Symmetry’s legal problems. Skidmore Owings & Merrill, the architecture firm that designed the River North tower, also has sued the developer, demanding payment of about $275,000 in design fees.

Symmetry did not return a call for comment, but the developer has not abandoned the project. It remains unclear whether it can pursue the development, however, given the existing buildings on the property are now protected from demolition, according to the report. [Crain’s] — Sasha Jones


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Bucksbaum Properties CEO John Bucksbaum (Getty, CMX Cinemas)
Bucksbaum sues movie chain Cinemex for $18M
Bucksbaum sues movie chain Cinemex for $18M
111 N. Canal St. (Google Maps)
Potbelly may be booted from West Loop HQ
Potbelly may be booted from West Loop HQ
James Loewenberg, with the Vista and Aqua Towers (Magellan)
Developer James Loewenberg dies; shaped modern Chicago skyline
Developer James Loewenberg dies; shaped modern Chicago skyline
Structured Development founding principal J. Michael Drew, whose company wants to now build 487 residential units as part of its mixed-use project on the Near North Side.
A really Big Deahl: Developer looks to upsize resi project
A really Big Deahl: Developer looks to upsize resi project
Vista Tower with (inset) Steve Vogel and Magellan Development CEO David Carlins (Vista, Bennington Marine)
Buyer of $10M Vista Tower condo sues Magellan after Wanda sells stake
Buyer of $10M Vista Tower condo sues Magellan after Wanda sells stake
From left: Fulton St. Companies co-founder Alex Najem & HSA Commercial CEO to Bob Smietana
“So much so fast”: Construction projects carry on, but local developers brace for shutdown
“So much so fast”: Construction projects carry on, but local developers brace for shutdown
(Credit: iStock)
Chicago EB-5 investors irate over Symmetry tower project
Chicago EB-5 investors irate over Symmetry tower project
Vermilion President & CEO Dave Cocagne, a rendering of 1650 West Division Street, and former Alderman Joe Moreno (Credit: Vermilion Development)
Lawsuit questions former alderman’s tactics in signing off on Wicker Park resi project
Lawsuit questions former alderman’s tactics in signing off on Wicker Park resi project
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...