The regulation situation

The precedent-setting rent regulation case that kept real estate lawyers (and landlords) busy this year

Oct.October 02, 2018 03:00 PM

New York Court of Appeals (Credit: Wikimedia Commons)

Considering that some 1 million New York City apartments are rent-regulated, cases with the potential to impact policy in that area are closely watched in real estate circles.

And this year one of those cases was front and center.

The case stems from a 2014 lawsuit filed by tenant Richard Altman against S.W. Management, claiming that the previous owner of his apartment had illegally deregulated it nine years earlier.

Related: The law firms with the highest volume of loans and sales

In 2015, much to the dismay of landlords citywide, a court ruled in Altman’s favor, ordering S.W. Management to pay him back $165,000 and drop his rent down to the $1,829 per month he was paying when the unit was deregulated.

But this past April, the New York Court of Appeals reversed the lower court’s 2015 decision.

The case — officially known as Altman v. 285 West Fourth LLC — could have resulted in more than 100,000 market-rate apartments reverting to regulated status.

“There was a lot riding on the case,” said Rosenberg & Estis’ Jeff Turkel, whose firm represented defendant S.W. Management in the case. “Literally thousands of apartments would have been reregulated if Altman had not been reversed. But as a result [of the ruling], the owners dodged a bullet. … That was a major win for the industry and a major blow to tenants.”

Related: NYC’s biggest real estate law firms

The April decision set a precedent that apartments deregulated between 1997 and 2011 didn’t need to strictly meet the $2,000 rent threshold for deregulation, which is triggered when a tenant vacates a unit.

Attorneys who work in the space characterized the ruling as the most significant decision concerning regulated apartments since 2009, when Stuyvesant Town tenant Amy Roberts sued owner Tishman Speyer. That case centered on stabilized units at the massive housing complex. A judge found that property owners tapping the J-51 tax break for improving buildings could not also use luxury decontrol to deregulate apartments.

The S.W. Management ruling, experts said, helps resolve conflicting court decisions.

“When [the 2015 decision] came down, it cratered the entire landscape of deregulation because it was such a significant departure from what was widely accepted law,” said Matt Brett, an attorney at Belkin Burden Wenig & Goldman.

Brett — who represented the landlord group Community Housing Improvement Program, the Rent Stabilization Association and the Real Estate Board of New York as amici curiae supporting S.W. Management in the Richards case — added that it “led to a lot of chaos.”

Brett said this latest decision gives investors more assurance about the free-market status of apartments deregulated before 2015.

“It does give more clarity and certainty to prior deregulations so that owners can understand with confidence that the deregulation they had done — as long as they followed the rules that were in place — were appropriate,” he said.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Matt Lauer exposes Hamptons estate to the market
Matt Lauer exposes Hamptons estate to the market
Matt Lauer exposes Hamptons estate to the market
 Fredrik Eklund and the property (Getty, Steve Frankel)
Fredrik Eklund lists Bel Air mansion for rent as family moves to “forever home”
Fredrik Eklund lists Bel Air mansion for rent as family moves to “forever home”
Gordon Ramsey and his Lucky Cat restaurant (Lucky Cat)
Gordon Ramsay to open first South Florida restaurant in Miami Beach
Gordon Ramsay to open first South Florida restaurant in Miami Beach
Marcelo Claure (Credit: Getty Images)
The $2 billion man? Marcelo Claure seeks top pay from SoftBank
The $2 billion man? Marcelo Claure seeks top pay from SoftBank
You’ll have to shell out another $15M for this private Bahamas island
You’ll have to shell out another $15M for this private Bahamas island
You’ll have to shell out another $15M for this private Bahamas island
(DOB)
City hit with lawsuit over Black workers’ treatment at Dept. of Buildings
City hit with lawsuit over Black workers’ treatment at Dept. of Buildings
Mustang, Texas is now owned by billionaire Mark Cuban. (J Elmer Turner Realtors, Inc.)
Mark Cuban buys a Mustang (well, a town called Mustang) in Texas
Mark Cuban buys a Mustang (well, a town called Mustang) in Texas
The Georgetown house once owned by Julia Child (Zillow)
Georgetown home where Julia Child lived hits market for $3.5 million
Georgetown home where Julia Child lived hits market for $3.5 million
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...