Supreme Court refuses to hear WeHo developers’ case against affordable housing subsidies

Developers were forced to pay a $540,000 fee for an 11-unit condo permit

Los Angeles /
Oct.October 31, 2017 04:00 PM

The Supreme Court said Monday it will not be hearing an appeal from West Hollywood developers fighting a California law that requires developers to subsidize affordable housing, the Los Angeles Times reported.

Jonathan and Shelah Lehrer-Graiwer were required to pay a fee of $540,000 to subsidize affordable housing elsewhere as part of their permit process for an 11-unit condo project at 616 N. Croft Avenue. The developers paid the fee but later sued in December 2012.

According to the inclusionary housing ordinance, developers are required to build and set aside a number of units for affordable housing or pay a fee set by a formula as a condition for receiving a permit.

The developers argued that the fees violate the Constitution’s prohibition of using private property “for public use without just compensation.” They also argued that permit restrictions must be related to the impact of a new development.

A state appeals court rejected the challenge – stating that the ordinance qualifies as a “land use regulation” because it does not “deprive a property owner of all viable economic use of the property.” The California courts said the fees are not an “exaction” of property, but rather a reasonable regulation of development.

Pacific Legal Foundation lawyers then appealed this decision in hopes the high court will enforce limits “on a government’s authority to use the permit process to force private property to dedicate private property to a public use.” [LAT] – Natalie Hoberman


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Standard Communities Co-Founders Scott Alter and Jeffrey Jaeger with the Union South Bay complex (Standard Communities)
Standard Communities buys 350-unit complex in Carson
Standard Communities buys 350-unit complex in Carson
Witkoff Group CEO Steve Witkoff, Simon and David Reuben and The West Hollywood Edition (Getty, Witkoff)
Reuben brothers look to foreclose on Witkoff’s West Hollywood Edition
Reuben brothers look to foreclose on Witkoff’s West Hollywood Edition
The Hollywood & Western Building (WikiMedia via Downtowngal)
Landmarked Hollywood office complex will become affordable housing
Landmarked Hollywood office complex will become affordable housing
Anaheim Councilmember Trevor O’Neil  (Facebook, iStock)
In Orange County, pushback over state’s homebuilding goal
In Orange County, pushback over state’s homebuilding goal
9900 Beverly (Binyan Studios)
Angelo Gordon JV lands $231M inventory loan on luxury condo project
Angelo Gordon JV lands $231M inventory loan on luxury condo project
The State Building and Construction Trades Council president Robbie Hunter (CA Building Trades, iStock)
State could require union labor on all affordable housing projects
State could require union labor on all affordable housing projects
A rendering of La Veranda (Abode Communities)
Affordable projects in Boyle Heights and Winnetka get LA city bond financing
Affordable projects in Boyle Heights and Winnetka get LA city bond financing
Residences at Westgate, The Hudson and Waterford co-founder John Drachman (Waterford Property Company, the CSCDA)
Waterford Property pays $335M for 2 Pasadena rental complexes
Waterford Property pays $335M for 2 Pasadena rental complexes
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...