LA Controller criticizes city record of negotiating big hotel tax breaks

A report says LA needs better guidelines and expertise, which could impact four projects going forward

Aug.August 14, 2018 09:40 AM
LA Controller Ron Galperin and Wilshire Grand

Ron Galperin, controller for the City of Los Angeles, put a magnifying glass to the city’s big tax break deals with major hotel developers and his office didn’t like what they found.

The city needs to do a better job evaluating and negotiating its deals, and make them more transparent, the Los Angeles City Controller’s Office wrote in a 29-page report released Friday.

The controller found that since the mid-2000s the city had approved projects “without having a broader, comprehensive Citywide economic development strategy.” That included several deals that were part of the nearly $1 billion in tax breaks the city has negotiated since 2005. Curbed first reported the news on Monday.

The report studied five deals totaling $654 million in tax breaks made between 2005 and 2015, including Hanjin International’s Wilshire Grand, which received $61 million in tax breaks, and the Village at Westfield Topanga.

Los Angeles typically makes tax incentive deals when developers are facing a funding gap, or feasibility gap, that would stall development. The idea is that losing that tax revenue is worth the economic benefit the development brings.

Galperin said the city should bring in an expert — either on the city payroll or as a consultant — that can best determine if a project actually needs financial assistance. That would put the city in a better negotiating position with the developer, he said.

The controller noted that the city failed to negotiate the best deal in some of the five cases it examined. For example, the formula used to determine the feasibility gap at Wilshire Grand “deviated” from the typical formula used “as a result of attorney negotiations.”

The report could impact ongoing negotiations with developers on four other projects, including Ventus Group’s 4.4-acre mixed-use Fig Project near Exposition Park.

[Curbed] – Dennis Lynch

Related Articles

Mitchell Englander in front of L.A. City Hall (Credit: Lilly Lawrence/Getty Images, and iStock)

Ex-LA council member surrenders to FBI in real estate probe

David Ryu (Credit: Getty Images)

LA becomes 1st city to enact ban on developer money

From left: Jose Huizar, Huang Wei, Mohamed Hadid, Robert Herscu, Raymond Chan, and Arman Gabay, with Los Angeles City Hall (Credit: iStock and Getty Images)

Real estate’s role in LA corruption scandals

From left: Governor Gavin Newsom, Assemblymember David Chiu, Senator Holly Mitchell, and Senator Nancy Skinner (Credit: Getty Images)

Here are the key housing and rent control bills state lawmakers are debating

Assemblymember Phil Ting

Statewide pot shop bill gets smoked

Assemblymember David Chui

Opponents of statewide bill to cap rent increases call it “disincentive” to build

Councilmen Blumenfield and Cedillo with City Hall

City Council’s plan to restrict developer donations faces Council pushback

Inglewood Mayor James T. Butts

Inglewood spent millions soundproofing wealthier homes from LAX noise