RIP SB 50: Housing bill that would have boosted density fails again

Legislation that would have allowed developers to go taller falls 3 votes short in state Senate

Jan.January 30, 2020 12:59 PM
Sen. Scott Wiener’s AB 50 fails to get enough votes (Credit: Getty Images and iStock)
Sen. Scott Wiener’s SB 50 fails to get enough votes (Credit: Getty Images and iStock)

The latest legislative proposal to address California’s deepening housing crisis by boosting density fell just short of the needed votes in the state Senate.

Senators on Thursday voted 18 to 15 in favor of the high-density housing bill known as SB 50 — three short of the required number. Six senators were marked as absent for the vote. It followed several failed votes over the last two days. The Senate still has until Friday —when the bill expires — but legislators were not scheduled to be in session.

Now the question is whether the SB 50’s sponsor, San Francisco Sen. Scott Wiener, will seek to revive the legislation.

Wiener conceived the legislation three years ago as a way to make it easier for developers to build taller, high-density housing around transit stations and employment hubs.

The bill has gone through a number of versions, but has still come under tremendous scrutiny, especially in Los Angeles and San Francisco. Single-family homeowners have pushed particularly hard for its defeat, arguing it would damage their neighborhoods and push down property values.

L.A. City Councilman Paul Koretz has also been a vocal opponent. In a letter to the editor published Tuesday in the Los Angeles Times, Koretz said the legislation “has the potential to decimate every single-family neighborhood in Los Angeles while also worsening our affordable housing shortage.”

Before the vote, Weiner urged his fellow lawmakers to “look at the big picture.”

“The numbers could not be more stark,” Wiener said. “We are short 3.5 million homes in California. This isn’t a small problem. This is a massive problem.”

Weiner said that when the ratio of homes per capita is calculated for all 50 states, California ranks one state from the bottom.

“We need to zone California to actually be able to build enough housing in a way that will not create sprawl,” he said. “This is about real people not just about numbers This is about Californians who are hurting right now.”

Related Articles

From left: Community Preservation Partners President Anand Kannan and Jonathan Rose Companies founder: Jonathan F.P. Rose, with the Golden West Tower Apartments (Credit: Google Maps and iStock)

Affordable developer teams up to buy Torrance senior housing complex

Regulatory fees are culprit in housing building costs (Credit: iStock)

It costs $500K to build one affordable housing unit in LA

A rendering of the project (Credit: Ian Espinoza Associates vis Urbanize)

Westfield adds affordable units to $1.5B Promenade redevelopment

Developers Mark and Arman Gabay are suing the city for rejecting their 577-unit District Square project in South L.A. (Credit: Department of City Planning via LA Times)

Gabays sue LA after it rejects their 577-unit resi project

Dr. Jayasinghe and a rendering of the project (Credit: Metro via Curbed)

Metro rejects plastic surgeon’s 907-unit development in Westlake

LA city council members want to close “loophole” in rent control law

LA measure would make it tougher for landlords to force out tenants for renovations

LA Chamber of Commerce, under CEO Maria Salinas,  explores ballot measure doubling density of resi buildings. (Photo credit: iStock Photo, LA Chamber of Commerce.)

LA Chamber of Commerce explores doubling density of resi buildings

A late-inning Jerry Brown housing bill is meant to expedite construction of supportive housing units

Affordable housing developer proposes 73-unit complex in San Fernando Valley