Landlords sue California over eviction ban

Lawsuit accuses California Judicial Council of overreaching

Los Angeles /
Jun.June 15, 2020 05:40 PM
Tani Cantil-Sakauye (Credit: Earl Gibson III/Getty Images)
Tani Cantil-Sakauye (Credit: Earl Gibson III/Getty Images)

Two landlords have filed a lawsuit against the California Judicial Council, the state court’s rulemaking body, hoping to end the state’s eviction suspension amid the coronavirus pandemic.

“The rule creates the perverse incentive for all tenants, whether they face financial hardship or not, to refuse to pay their rent during the crisis,” reads the lawsuit filed by the libertarian leaning Pacific Legal Foundation. “And it immunizes from eviction tenants who create nuisances, damage property, conduct illegal activity, or violate lease terms.”

The lawsuit filed in Kern County Court on Monday is the latest escalation in California residential landlords’ fight against state and local government, to say nothing of tenants and mortgage lenders. It comes one week after the Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles trade group filed a complaint against the city of Los Angeles’s eviction moratorium.

In April, the Judicial Council, led by California Supreme Court Justice Tani-Cantil Sakauye, told state courts to not process residential and commercial eviction motions landlords file until 90 days after Gov. Gavin Newsom lifts California’s state of emergency order.

The Judicial Council met last week to revisit the eviction suspension, but did not vote on scrapping the rule.

The lawsuit says the order abuses California’s separation of powers. “The Judicial Council made a classic policy decision that is properly the legislature’s domain, not the Judicial Council’s,” the lawsuit reads.

The landlords who sued, Peggy Christensen of Mojave and Peter Martin of Arcata in Humboldt County, are described as saddled by problem tenants.

Martin, for example, called on Humboldt County court to evict a tenant for “disturbing the other tenants by engaging in unlawful drug activities on the premises”

But the court “refused to issue a summons” due to the emergency rule.

A Judicial Council spokesperson said the group does not comment on pending litigation. The Council has not set a date on when it might reevaluate the eviction ban.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
RBM's Hiro Kobayashi with 11264 La Grange Avenue
RBM buys film company HQ in Sawtelle for undisclosed price
RBM buys film company HQ in Sawtelle for undisclosed price
ApartmentList's Rob Warnock (ApartmentList, Getty)
LA rents dip in December, still higher than pre-pandemic
LA rents dip in December, still higher than pre-pandemic
From left: Lexington Apartments, 1221 Ocean, Thea at Metropolis, and Vue Los Feliz
$500M sale tops list of LA multifamily deals in 2022
$500M sale tops list of LA multifamily deals in 2022
Beach City Capital's Jason Muller with rendering of 12763 Mitchell Avenue (Beach City Capital)
Beach City Capital to start work on Mar Vista apartments
Beach City Capital to start work on Mar Vista apartments
8747 Parthenia Place in North Hills (Google Maps, Getty)
Parthenia Partners to build 55 apartments in North Hills
Parthenia Partners to build 55 apartments in North Hills
(Getty; Illustration by The Real Deal)
Los Angeles rents rise 11% for two-bedroom apartments
Los Angeles rents rise 11% for two-bedroom apartments
CBRE's Dean Zander and CBRE’s Stuart Weston with a rendering of Rize Irvine (LinkedIn, CBRE, Zillow)
Rize Irvine apartment complex trades for $190M
Rize Irvine apartment complex trades for $190M
Schon Tepler's Paul Schon and 749 Gramercy Drive (Redfin, Getty, courtesy of Paul Schon)
Schon Tepler and partner list Koreatown co-living development for $29M
Schon Tepler and partner list Koreatown co-living development for $29M
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...