LA’s outdoor dining ban stands despite judge’s harsh rebuke

State stay-at-home order means county restaurants must remain closed for dining

Los Angeles /
Dec.December 09, 2020 11:00 AM
Gov. Gavin Newsom (Getty, iStock)
Gov. Gavin Newsom (Getty, iStock)

A judge’s decision to overturn Los Angeles County’s outdoor dining ban has no practical effect because of the state’s current stay-at-home order.

Tuesday’s ruling by L.A. County Superior Court Judge James Chalfant was a strong rebuke. As part of a 53-page written decision, he said the county’s “own data provide no support for the planned shutdown of outdoor restaurant operations.”

Despite the scathing words, the ruling will not change the suspension on dining in the county, according to the Los Angeles Times. That’s because California’s Covid order — which limits restaurants to takeout only — supersedes the county measure.

The state-level order took effect in L.A. County and surrounding counties over the weekend. It kicks in when any region of the state records intensive care unit bed availability below 15 percent.

Barely 10 percent of ICU beds in the state-designated Southern California region, which stretches as far north as Mono County, are available.

Chalfant said if the county wants to extend its ban on outdoor dining beyond the state order, it will have to conduct a risk-benefit analysis.

“The issue here is, is shutting down outdoor dining going to help in any significant way, or is it just something to do?” Chalfant said at a court hearing Tuesday.

He also said the order “is an abuse of the [county health department’s] emergency power.”

The county’s outdooring dining ban was harshly criticized by businesses and restaurant representatives, along with some local elected officials. The city of Pasadena broke with the county and allowed outdoor dining, but ultimately shut it down because of the state order.

Several other types of businesses and activities are barred under the state order, including hair salons and breweries. Residents are asked to keep both public and private gatherings to a minimum. [LAT] — Dennis Lynch 


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Disney Store at Montebello Town Center (Disney, Shops at Montebello)
Mall vs. The Mouse: UBS sues Disney store for $275K in back rent
Mall vs. The Mouse: UBS sues Disney store for $275K in back rent
Sandstone Properties CEO Eri Kroh with a rendering of the project (Sandstone, The Jeff Hotel)
Culver City approves `The Jeff,’ Sandstone Properties’ 175-unit hotel
Culver City approves `The Jeff,’ Sandstone Properties’ 175-unit hotel
Renderings of the expansion, including the J.W. Marriott hotel (Saiful Bouquet)
Details of transformative LA Convention Center expansion emerge
Details of transformative LA Convention Center expansion emerge
The L.A. County median of $790,000 was 23 percent higher than last June (Getty)
SoCal home prices reach yet another record high in June
SoCal home prices reach yet another record high in June
California will use nearly $3 billion from the federal government to convert motels into housing for homeless over next two years, part of a $5 billion budget package to address homelessness (Getty)
Project Homekey gets $2.75B in fed funding
Project Homekey gets $2.75B in fed funding
L.A. County property assessor Jeff Prang (iStock, L.A. County Assessor)
Despite pandemic, LA County property values rise by $63B
Despite pandemic, LA County property values rise by $63B
The latest measure comes a month after the state lifted most restrictions. (Getty)
LA County retailers, indoor venues must mask (back) up
LA County retailers, indoor venues must mask (back) up
Street performers on Hollywood Boulevard as retail and tourism recovers in the state (Getty)
Newsom signs small business grants as part of relief package
Newsom signs small business grants as part of relief package
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...