L.A. Alliance doubles down on federal lawsuit over homelessness solution

Downtown coalition will press its case against L.A. County, after $3B settlement with City of LA

Los Angeles /
Apr.April 08, 2022 02:05 PM
L.A. Alliance for Human Rights' Elizabeth Mitchell (Getty, L.A. Alliance for Human Rights)
L.A. Alliance for Human Rights’ Elizabeth Mitchell (Getty, L.A. Alliance for Human Rights)

A coalition of Downtown property owners, residents and homeless individuals will move forward with a federal lawsuit against Los Angeles County to demand a solution to widespread homelessness.

The L.A. Alliance for Human Rights said in a court filing it anticipates a second amended complaint against the county “will significantly streamline the case” – if and when the court signs off on a recent settlement with the City of Los Angeles, the Los Angeles Daily News reported.

On April 1, the city settled its portion of the March 2020 lawsuit, leaving the county open as a defendant.

Under the settlement, the city of L.A. agreed to spend as much as $3 billion over the next five years to create up to 16,000 beds or housing units for the homeless — enough to shelter 60 percent of its homeless residents. Los Angeles has 36,000 homeless residents; the county has 66,000.

City officials said the county should be responsible for housing and providing services for those living on the street with serious mental illnesses, physical maladies and drug addiction – since the county has medical and mental health facilities, and the city doesn’t.

By shifting responsibility to the county for sheltering the sick and vulnerable, the city reduced the number of homeless people it would have to house.

In February, U.S. District Judge David O. Carter ordered a series of mandatory settlement talks after city and county representatives indicated they had no sense of when or if they might strike a deal that would lead to an agreement. A few weeks ago, the county withdrew from the multiple hours of discussions.

Carter has pointed to a “historic schism” between the city and county that had apparently frustrated an eventual settlement. The two jurisdictions were supposed to reach a compromise on funding and other issues before a final agreement with the L.A. Alliance.

An attorney for the L.A. Alliance, Elizabeth Mitchell, told reporters the county has “refused to participate in this settlement.”
“We will not stop working to hold the county accountable,” she said. “This crisis is too big for any one branch of government. The county is not getting out of its obligations.”

The lawsuit brought by the L.A. Alliance initially aimed to force local governments to “comprehensively” solve the homelessness crisis in Skid Row, an area in Downtown L.A. The suit was then expanded to include homeless populations along freeways, then to the unhoused population at large.

Skip Miller, outside counsel for the county, has argued the county should not be held accountable for Downtown L.A. because “the city has primary jurisdiction.” On April 1, he said the lawsuit “has no merit with regard to the county.”
“It is between the plaintiffs and the city, and we’re glad they settled,” he said. “We intend to litigate and win this case. The county is more than doing its job and doing everything possible to address homelessness without stigmatizing it as a crime.”

[LA Daily News] – Dana Bartholomew





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    TCW's David Lippman with and the City National Plaza at 515 S. Flower Street (David Lippman, City National Plaza)
    TCW inks largest pandemic-era office lease in DTLA
    TCW inks largest pandemic-era office lease in DTLA
    Joel Schreiber and 801 South Broadway (Google Maps)
    WeWork’s first investor in grind on DTLA’s Broadway Trade Center
    WeWork’s first investor in grind on DTLA’s Broadway Trade Center
     1933 South Broadway (Loopnet, iStock)
    Ara Tavitian scores $150M refi on The Reef in DTLA
    Ara Tavitian scores $150M refi on The Reef in DTLA
    GI Partners' Rick Magnuson and One Wilshire (GI Partners, One Wilshire)
    Here’s how much tenants are paying at One Wilshire in DTLA
    Here’s how much tenants are paying at One Wilshire in DTLA
    Mayor Eric Garcetti (Wikipedia, iStock)
    City of LA approves settlement to spend $3B to house the homeless
    City of LA approves settlement to spend $3B to house the homeless
    Coretrust Capital Partners' Thomas Ricci, Randall Scott and John Sischo; 444 S. Flower Street, Los Angeles (444 South Flower, iStock, Coretrust Capital Partners)
    Coretrust leases 44K sf of offices to law firms in DTLA
    Coretrust leases 44K sf of offices to law firms in DTLA
    empty lot (iStock)
    Critics see thousands of “fake sites” in SoCal housing plans
    Critics see thousands of “fake sites” in SoCal housing plans
    L.A. County Supervisor Kathryn Barger (Getty Images, iStock)
    LA County to create new agency to focus on homelessness
    LA County to create new agency to focus on homelessness
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...