Miami Beach enacts developer-specific ethics ordinance

Critics say measure falls short; commissioners called it "strictest in the state"

Jan.January 14, 2016 09:45 AM

Miami Beach commissioners unanimously enacted a new ordinance on Wednesday that prevents commissioners, political candidates and their supporters from soliciting contributions from vendors doing business with the city or lobbyists for PACS.

The legislation was proposed after developer contributions became a heated issue in citywide elections last year that saw three new commissioners elected and Mayor Philip Levine re-elected. A PAC linked to former commissioner Jonah Wolfson raised an estimated $1.4 million – an unprecedented sum by Miami Beach standards – from a slew of developers and others with significant business interests at City Hall.

Commissioners and the mayor praised the new legislation. Commissioner Michael Grieco called the ordinance “the strictest in the state” when it comes to ethics and Levine told The Real Deal that the city now “has a code and ordinance that specifically defines developers,” and said “developers are defined as those coming before the city for a development agreement.” Levine added “those particular class of developers would be unable to directly or indirectly contribute to candidates running for office in Miami Beach.”

But critics said the ordinance does not go far enough. Civic activist Frank Del Vecchio said that while there are positive aspects to the new ordinance, the legislation was drafted “so narrowly, it’s like the eye of the needle.” Del Vecchio said the city’s definition of what constitutes a “real estate developer” is so narrow that the ordinance would only cover two of the 63 developers with city projects in 2015, leaving 97 percent of developers free to make political contributions to candidates or campaigns.

Some commissioners on Wednesday voiced support for expanding the definition of what constitutes a real estate developer, but city attorney Raul Aguila cautioned commissioners that any such move to do so could be challenged in court on First Amendment grounds. “As all of us know the Supreme Court of this land is becoming increasingly liberal with regard to campaign contributions,” Aguila told the commission. He added, “We’re pushing the envelope as far as we can but at the same time we have to be conscious of the law of the land.”

Related Articles

From left: Edgardo Defortuna, Stephan Burke, Ron Shuffield, Ana Bozovic, Carol Cassis, and Mark Zilbert

South Florida’s residential sales shift to virtual reality as business slows

From left: Eden Roc and BLT Prime Trump National Doral (Credit: Acroterion/Wikipedia, and Trump International Hotels Management LLC)

Trump National Doral restaurant, Eden Roc hotel lay off hundreds

The city of Miami Beach issued a stay-at-home order (Credit: iStock)

Miami Beach becomes first South Florida city to order residents to stay at home

From left: Miami Beach Mayor Dan Gelber, and Miami-Dade Mayor Carlos Gimenez (Credit: Twitter, Ryan Holloway/ Armando Rodriguez Miami-Dade County Photographers, and iStock)

All hotels, short-term rentals in Miami-Dade ordered to shut down due to coronavirus

5242 North Bay Road and Cyril Matz (Credit: Google Maps)

Waterfront North Bay Road home sells for $7M

4403 Pine Tree Drive with Mendel Fellig and Oren Alexander (Credit: Douglas Elliman, Sean Zanni/Patrick McMullan via Getty Images)

Car insurance mogul flips Miami Beach waterfront estate

Daniel Glass and Eighty Seven Park (Credit: Charley Gallay/Getty Images for Citi)

Music exec, Goldman Sachs director snag condos at Eighty Seven Park

Anthony Kennedy Shriver and Alina Shriver (Credit: Venturelli/WireImage/Getty Images)

JFK’s nephew sells waterfront Miami Beach home