Wynwood opposes legislation aimed at making developers pay for public art in Miami

"If this existed five to 10 years ago, Wynwood woud not exist:" Albert Garcia, vice chairman of Wynwood BID

Miami /
Oct.October 11, 2017 06:00 PM

Wynwood developers and property owners are officially taking a stand against proposed legislation that would force them to either subject their private art projects to city appraisals or pay a percentage of their development costs in lieu of placing art installations.

The Wynwood Business Improvement District’s board of directors voted unanimously on Wednesday to rescind its previous support for two resolutions that would expand the city of Miami’s art in public places program beyond city-owned properties. The Miami City Commission will take a second reading vote on the measures on Thursday.

“This is a big problem for us as a neighborhood,” said BID board member David Lombardi. “This is a tax.”

Albert Garcia, the BID board’s vice chairman, said the ramifications will also hurt other emerging neighborhoods like Allapattah, Little Haiti and Little Havana. “This legislation is a clear and present danger to their ongoing evolution,” Garcia said. “If this existed five to 10 years ago, Wynwood woud not exist.”

More than a year ago, the Wynwood BID provided the city’s planning department a letter of support based on assurances that the trendy, arts-driven neighborhood would get to set up its own rules for what constitutes public art installations on private properties, said board member David Polinsky.

However, the current draft of the legislation dilutes the power Wynwood stakeholders would have over any public art program they develop for the district because it would still need final approval from an art in public places board set up for the entire city, the planning and zoning director and the city commission, Polinsky said. In addition, installations made by young and emerging artists contracted by Wynwood developers and property owners would not qualify as public art, he said.

“The city had previously promised us a carve out,” Polinsky said. “Instead, what we got was a one-and-a-half year grace period. We need to send a clear message that we are rescinding our support.

In a previous interview, Efren Nuñez, Miami’s acting historic preservation officer who was heavily involved in drafting the public art legislation, downplayed concerns that the legislation is going to hurt Wynwood.  “On the contrary, our goal is to grow the local artist community,” Nuñez said at the time. “Where you now only have a few developers interested in public art, now every development over $3 million will have to create public art.”

In January, the city commission adopted legislation requiring public art be placed on city-owned sites after city staffers spent nearly two years tweaking the existing program to bring it into compliance with Miami-Dade County’s rules for art in public places. However, commissioners instructed Nuñez to work on legislation that would win the support of the private development community.

Nuñez came up with a proposal similar to ones implemented in other cities such as Doral, Miami Beach and Coral Gables. Developers and property owners can opt out by paying between 0.25 percent to 1 percent of a project’s development cost. A higher cost of construction means an owner pays a higher percentage. If a developer or owner decides to place art installations, the work would have to go through an appraisal, be insured and remain permanent.

Polinsky argued that Wynwood’s public art installations largely consist of wall murals that are often replaced within a short period of time. “Basically, if we have to live with the legislation as drafted, none of the dollars we currently spend on [putting art on] buildings would meet the criteria,” he said. “It is cheaper to pay the fee than put up the art.”


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Rendering of the Dorsey with Alex Karakhanian, Jon Paul Perez and Tricera’s Scott Sherman and Ben Mandel (iStock)

Related scores $88M construction loan for Dorsey project in Wynwood

Related scores $88M construction loan for Dorsey project in Wynwood
Ben Bernstein and Ryan Shear with a rendering of the project at 2407 Northwest 2nd Avenue, Miami (RedSky, PMG, Google Maps)

PMG adds to assemblage of planned Society Wynwood project

PMG adds to assemblage of planned Society Wynwood project
Michael Stern and a rendering of the project (Getty, JDS Development/SHoP Archictects)

Michael Stern pays $24M for future site of 62-story Brickell tower

Michael Stern pays $24M for future site of 62-story Brickell tower
Goldman Properties' Jessica Goldman Srebnick with 2501 Northwest 5th Avenue and the lot at 413 Northwest 25th Street, Miami (Getty, iStock)

Goldman Properties buys Wynwood property for discounted $5M

Goldman Properties buys Wynwood property for discounted $5M
Pharrell Williams and David Lerner with a photo of 2545 Northwest Third Avenue and a rendering of the Billionaire Boys Club exterior (Getty, Google Maps, Lerner Family Properties)

Pharrell’s Billionaire Boys Club to open store in Wynwood

Pharrell’s Billionaire Boys Club to open store in Wynwood
1396 Northwest 36th Street with Integra's Paulo Tavares de Melo and EHDOC's Melanie Ribeiro (Photos via Getty; LinkedIn)

Integra, partner move forward with $58M senior housing project in Allapattah

Integra, partner move forward with $58M senior housing project in Allapattah
Angel Febres, partner, Homecookin’ Hospitality and Metro 1 Managing Director Andres Nava

Wynwood nightclub building hits the market

Wynwood nightclub building hits the market
Domio Wynwood, Gustavo Miculitzki, and Jon Paul Pérez (Credit: Alberto Tamargo/Getty Images)

Related lists Domio Wynwood apartment-hotel for sale with whisper price of $90M

Related lists Domio Wynwood apartment-hotel for sale with whisper price of $90M
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...