Miami Design District building allegedly lost $5M in value due to billboard ban: lawsuit

The owner wants the city of Miami to pay for the diminished value of its property at 100 Northeast 38th Street

Miami /
Mar.March 07, 2019 04:30 PM

100 Northeast 38th Street (Credit: Google Maps)

The owner of a commercial building in the Miami Design District is suing the city for approving a billboard ban that allegedly sunk the value of the property by nearly $5 million.

Karenza Apartments LLP, which owns the building at 100 Northeast 38th Street, alleges it also lost a lucrative contract with a billboard advertiser after city commissioners passed the measure that prohibits billboards north of I-95, at the behest of Miami Design District developer Craig Robins of Dacra.

Attorneys for the city and Karenza declined comment. Documents attached to the lawsuit list Michael Siegel, a Cooper City-based accountant, as the company’s managing partner. A spokesperson for Dacra, that along with partner L Real Estate has redeveloped the Miami Design District into a luxury retail destination, did not respond to two emails seeking comment.

According to the complaint, the city commission passed the ban on second reading on July 27, 2017, about a year after it was introduced by Commissioner Keon Hardemon at Robins’ request. At the time, Karenza had an agreement with Becker Boards Miami to place a large mural above its one-story property, which is currently occupied by the offices of architecture firm Shulman + Associates. Karenza’s building was one of three properties in the Design District with billboard permits, the lawsuit states.

Karenza claims the city commission ignored a planning and zoning appeals board recommendation that its building be grandfathered in because the proposed measure included an exemption for one of the other neighboring billboard properties, at 3704 Northeast Second Avenue.

At a hearing two months before the city commission’s vote, planning board members “noted the inherent and unwarranted inequity of treating [Karenza’s] property and the 3704 Northeast Second Avenue property…differently,” the lawsuit claims.

“The appeals board also noted the unusual manner in which the Miami Design District had influenced the proposed ordinance, the boundaries of the geographic area and the mural rights of properties outside the Miami Design District special area plan,” the complaint alleges.

On Aug. 26, 2017, when the ban took effect, Becker Boards Miami relocated its mural to a property south of I-195 since Karenza’s property was no longer allowed to have billboards. Karenza is suing the city for $4.8 million in damages, which represents the dollar amount of the property’s diminished value, the suit states.

According to an appraisal attached to the lawsuit, Karenza’s property was worth $13.4 million until the day the ban went into effect and Becker Boards moved its mural. The property is now worth $8.6 million, per the appraisal.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Julie Jones (Getty)
Florida Luxurious Properties sues ex-partner Julie Jones over Elliman jump
Florida Luxurious Properties sues ex-partner Julie Jones over Elliman jump
From left: Monroe Capital’s Theodore Koenig, Steve Witkoff, HFZ's Ziel Feldman and Benny Shabtai with the Shore Club (Monroe, Witkoff, HFZ, Getty)
Judge awards $5M to Israeli mogul in HFZ lawsuit over failed Shore Club project in Miami Beach
Judge awards $5M to Israeli mogul in HFZ lawsuit over failed Shore Club project in Miami Beach
Carillon Miami Wellness Resort at 6801 Collins Avenue in Miami Beach (Google Maps, Getty)
Z Capital loses attempt to slap Miami Beach condo owners with $8M assessment
Z Capital loses attempt to slap Miami Beach condo owners with $8M assessment
Domenic Gatto and Banyan Cay Resort and Club (Linkedin, Banyan Cay, Illustration by The Real Deal with Getty)
Developers of troubled West Palm resort project facing $61M foreclosure
Developers of troubled West Palm resort project facing $61M foreclosure
KAR Properties' Shahab Karmely and  Suffolk Construction's  Peter Tuffo with 2000 Ocean  (Suffolk, KAR, Getty)
Suffolk sues for $16M, alleging unpaid work at Shahab Karmely’s Hallandale Beach condo project
Suffolk sues for $16M, alleging unpaid work at Shahab Karmely’s Hallandale Beach condo project
From left: Witkoff’s Steve Witkoff and Monroe Capital’s Theodore Koenig with the Shore Club
Witkoff, Monroe sued over alleged “crooked and secretive land grab” of Shore Club in South Beach
Witkoff, Monroe sued over alleged “crooked and secretive land grab” of Shore Club in South Beach
Adeena Weiss Ortiz and map view of 4865 Northwest 7th Street in Miami (WeissOrtiz Law, Google Maps)
Caroline Weiss locked in legal conflict with daughter over $21M loan tied to massive Blue Lagoon development
Caroline Weiss locked in legal conflict with daughter over $21M loan tied to massive Blue Lagoon development
Miami-Dade County Mayor Daniella Levine Cava, Attorney
Miami-Dade may help renters in eviction court secure attorneys
Miami-Dade may help renters in eviction court secure attorneys
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...