A-Rod’s ex-brother-in-law alleges racketeering, embezzlement in new lawsuit against retired Yankee

Rodriguez has built up his real estate empire since the early 2000s

Miami /
Jan.January 14, 2021 01:30 PM
Alex Rodriguez with Stuart Zook (Getty, Miami-Dade County Circuit Courts)

Alex Rodriguez with Stuart Zook (Getty, Miami-Dade County Circuit Courts/Illustration by Alexis Manrodt for The Real Deal)

Retired New York Yankees player and real estate investor Alex Rodriguez is facing new allegations of racketeering, embezzlement and fraud in a complaint filed by his ex-brother-in-law.

Constantine Scurtis is suing Rodriguez, Monument Capital Management principal Stuart Zook, Newport Property Ventures and other companies affiliated with Rodriguez. Scurtis alleges that he was the victim of a “systematic and fraudulent effort” to cut him out of the venture and to “strip him of the future financial rewards.”

The allegations date back to the early 2000s, when Rodriguez began investing in real estate. Scurtis is the brother of Rodriguez’s ex-wife, Cynthia, with whom he has two children.

The latest lawsuit, filed this month in Miami-Dade Circuit Court, is set for a trial to begin in August.

From left: Jose Gomez, Alex Rodriguez, Warren Buffett and Constantine Scurtis (Miami-Dade County Circuit Courts)

From left: Jose Gomez, Alex Rodriguez, Warren Buffett and Constantine Scurtis (Miami-Dade County Circuit Courts)

The complaint begins with the allegation that Rodriguez is “a serial cheater and liar” and that after allegedly cheating on Cynthia, he “lied to and cheated” Scurtis in their real estate partnership. Scurtis outlines allegations of embezzlement, obtaining property by fraud, insurance fraud, forgery, mail fraud and wire fraud, and claims that the alleged racketeering resulted in millions of dollars in damages to Scurtis.

According to the suit, the partnership was allegedly set up so that Scurtis would receive 5 percent of the profits, plus a 3 percent commission on purchases of properties that he would bring to Rodriguez.

Rodriguez’s attorney, John C. Lukacs Sr., said in a statement to The Real Deal that Scurtis’ claims are “baseless” and that Scurtis has amended his complaint four times, “asserting a hodgepodge of fabricated claims that are wholly without merit.”

Scurtis is now alleging that Rodriguez and his co-conspirators sold properties to themselves at “artificially low prices,” filed false records with the Florida Secretary of State and the Internal Revenue Service, and fabricated the transfer of Scurtis’ partnership interests to entities controlled by Rodriguez,” according to the complaint.

Katherine Eskovitz, a partner at New York and Miami-based Roche Cyrulnik Freedman who represents Scurtis, said in a statement that Rodriguez and his co-conspirators’ alleged actions “gravely [damaged] a legitimate and successful family real estate business that Constantine Scurtis built through hard work and savvy investment decisions.”

The lawsuit also alleges that Rodriguez, Zook and others falsified records to show that employees were renting properties in Tampa, and then allegedly reimbursed themselves for the rent payments by calling the reimbursements consulting payments. Scurtis also alleges insurance fraud following Hurricane Ike in 2008, claiming that two sets of accounting records were created, one with the actual damage caused by the hurricane and another with inflated damages.

Rodriguez’s attorney Lukacs added in his statement, “Sadly, Scurtis expanded his claims yet again to include and publicly sensationalize additional allegations as part of his scheme to impugn and shakedown Rodriguez for money which Scurtis is not entitled to, and to escape repayment of substantial monies owed which is the subject of a countersuit against him.”




    Correction: An earlier version of this story incorrectly stated what position Rodriguez played. 


    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Christian Slater with 3618 Saint Gaudens Road (Getty Images, 1oak Studios)
    Christian Slater sells Coconut Grove home after three-way bidding war
    Christian Slater sells Coconut Grove home after three-way bidding war
    Jeff Bezos and his parents, Jackie and Mike Bezos, with 9501 Journeys End Lane (Douglas Friedman, Getty)
    Jeff Bezos’ parents close on second Coral Gables mansion for $44M
    Jeff Bezos’ parents close on second Coral Gables mansion for $44M
    Tom Joyner with 469 Ocean Boulevard (Getty, Mike Ruiz)
    Tom Joyner sells oceanfront Golden Beach home for $19M
    Tom Joyner sells oceanfront Golden Beach home for $19M
    Jeff Bezos and his parents, Jackie and Mike Bezos, with 9475 Journeys End Road (Douglas Elliman Realty, Illustration by The Real Deal with Getty)
    Jeff Bezos’ parents tied to $34M purchase of waterfront Coral Gables mansion
    Jeff Bezos’ parents tied to $34M purchase of waterfront Coral Gables mansion
    Marc Anthony with One Thousand Museum (Getty, Refin)
    Marc Anthony among buyers at Zaha Hadid-designed One Thousand Museum
    Marc Anthony among buyers at Zaha Hadid-designed One Thousand Museum
    Rush and Kathryn Adams Limbaugh along with 1495 North Ocean Boulevard in Palm Beach (Getty Images, Zillow, iStock)
    Rush Limbaugh’s oceanfront Palm Beach estate marketed for sale, asking up to $175M
    Rush Limbaugh’s oceanfront Palm Beach estate marketed for sale, asking up to $175M
    Coldwell Banker's Danny Hertzberg (Jills Zeder Group, iStock)
    Renting homes to the ultra-wealthy brings its own set of headaches
    Renting homes to the ultra-wealthy brings its own set of headaches
    Nancy Shevell McCartney with Il Lugano (Getty, Apartments.com)
    Paul McCartney’s wife sells her late father’s Palm Beach condo
    Paul McCartney’s wife sells her late father’s Palm Beach condo
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...