Partner in South Beach’s Hotel Greystone hit with $19M judgment

James Vosotas is locked in a bitter legal war with former development partner Branden Muhl

Miami /
Jan.January 06, 2022 10:30 AM

From left: James Vosotas and Branden Muhl, former partners who teamed up to renovate and reopen Hotel Greystone (Vos Hospitality, Mahaska, LoopNet)

South Beach hotel partner James Vosotas got slapped with an $18.9 million judgment in New York Supreme Court.

Judge Andrew Borrok’s ruling on Tuesday against Vosotas and his company, Vos Hospitality, marks a significant blow in his ongoing legal war against his former friend and development partner, Branden Muhl, CEO of Mahaska, a national bottling and distribution company based in Oskaloosa, Iowa.

“Our client is disappointed in the decision,” William Clayton, Vosota’s attorney, said in a text message. “He is considering all options, including an appeal.”

Vosotas and Muhl had teamed up to renovate and reopen Hotel Greystone, an Art Deco property at 1920 Collins Avenue in Miami Beach. The partnership came apart shortly after the hotel’s grand opening was short-circuited by business lockdowns during the early days of the pandemic in 2020.

Vos Hospitality bought the property in 2012 for $7.5 million. Muhl claims he helped finance the acquisition, according to court documents. The ownership of the hotel was subsequently transferred to Greystone Hospitality, whose investors include Vos Hospitality and entities managed by Muhl.

In a lawsuit filed in New York in March of last year, Muhl’s company, BBM3, which acquired a $36 million construction loan in 2017 that was provided to the entities that own and operate Hotel Greystone, alleged Vosotas failed to meet his obligations under the loan guarantees.

Six months later, Vosotas, Vos Hospitality and Greystone Hospitality sued Muhl, BBM3 and five Greystone-related entities in Miami-Dade Circuit Court. Vosotas alleges that Muhl is attempting a hostile takeover with the New York lawsuit. He also accused his former pal of purposely keeping the hotel padlocked for most of 2020 and 2021 in order to sabotage the partnership and wipe out Vosotas’ ownership stake in the property, the Miami-Dade lawsuit states.

In the New York case, Judge Borrok determined that BBM3 had established proof that Vosotas owes $18.9 million in loan guarantees. Borrok also dismissed Vosota’s defense that the New York Supreme Court did not have jurisdiction because he resides in Florida and Hotel Greystone is in Miami Beach. “He agreed to come to New York to litigate this dispute if necessary, and the agreement is valid,” Borrok wrote.

In a statement, Muhl’s attorney Jason Friedman said Borrok’s ruling is an important victory for his client. “The order clearly establishes that Mr. Vosotas breached the guarantees and must be held accountable to the lender,” Friedman said. “The lender fully intends to collect the judgment.”

Clayton, Vosotas’ attorney, noted that Greystone Hospitality, the hotel’s current ownership entity, is not a party to the New York lawsuit. “The Miami case against BBM3 will continue undaunted,” Clayton said.

In the Miami-Dade lawsuit, Judge William Thomas had initially appointed a receiver in August to take over management and operations of Hotel Greystone. But a few days later, after Muhl’s lawyers argued a receiver wasn’t necessary, Thomas rescinded his order. Instead, Thomas appointed a court monitor to keep tabs on Hotel Greystone’s finances and business operations.

After initially opening Hotel Greystone as an adults-only hotel around Super Bowl LIV weekend in early 2020, the property was forced to close in mid-March due to business lockdowns. Muhl and Vosotas accused each other of preventing the hotel from reopening once those lockdowns were lifted, court filings show.

In September, Hotel Greystone reopened with new management under Provincetown, Massachusetts-based Salt Hotels.





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    554 Lakeview Dr, Miami Beach and Jarett Fein (Zillow, KV National)
    Title insurance honcho pays $15M for restored waterfront Mid-Miami Beach house
    Title insurance honcho pays $15M for restored waterfront Mid-Miami Beach house
    A photo illustration of Ocean House South Beach, 125 Ocean Drive (Condo.com, iStock)
    Ocean House South Beach closing tops weekly condo sales in Miami-Dade
    Ocean House South Beach closing tops weekly condo sales in Miami-Dade
    The Surfside collapse condo site at 8777 Collins Avenue (Getty)
    Surfside bidder gets extension for due diligence, pushing auction to April
    Surfside bidder gets extension for due diligence, pushing auction to April
    From left: Pedro Villar, owner of Aloft Miami Brickell, along with his attorney Joe Pack (Newstar Media)
    Aloft Miami-Brickell exits bankruptcy, staves off foreclosure
    Aloft Miami-Brickell exits bankruptcy, staves off foreclosure
    One Bal Harbour at 10295 Collins Avenue in Bal Harbour, FL (Seaside Properties Group, iStock/Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
    One Bal Harbour associations settle suit over shared utility, valet expenses
    One Bal Harbour associations settle suit over shared utility, valet expenses
    Ellen Hukkelhoven and 1300 Monad Terrace, penthouse F (World Medical Innovation Forum)
    Flipping out: Penthouse at Michael Stern’s Miami Beach project flips for 30% more in six months
    Flipping out: Penthouse at Michael Stern’s Miami Beach project flips for 30% more in six months
    RFR Holding's Aby Rosen (Getty), East End Capital's Jonathon Yormak (East End Capital) and 100 Biscayne Boulevard (iStock)
    Aby Rosen’s RFR buys 100 Biscayne office tower in downtown Miami for about $90M: sources
    Aby Rosen’s RFR buys 100 Biscayne office tower in downtown Miami for about $90M: sources
    Star Island estate lists for $90M following Ken Griffin’s nearby $75M record purchase
    Star Island estate lists for $90M following Ken Griffin’s nearby $75M record purchase
    Star Island estate lists for $90M following Ken Griffin’s nearby $75M record purchase
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...