Watermark Capital plots Dumbo office-to-resi play 

Firm acquired 175 Pearl Street for $67M

175 Pearl Street (CBRE, Getty)
175 Pearl Street (CBRE, Getty)

Office-to-residential conversions are logical pitches in Manhattan, but Brooklyn has at least one property primed to make a switch.

Watermark Capital Group is embarking on a conversion of 175 Pearl Street in the borough’s Dumbo neighborhood, the Commercial Observer reported. The plans would expand the eight-story, 185,000-square-foot office into luxury housing.

News of the plans comes shortly after Wolfe Landau’s firm acquired the property from Cannon Hill Capital Partners for $66.5 million. BridgeCity Capital provided $50.6 million in acquisition financing.

Landau plans to convert the 1918-built property into a 14-story, 238-unit multifamily complex, which would span 230,000 square feet. The conversion doesn’t require a rezoning and is set to benefit from 467-M, a new state tax incentive that aids conversions by exempting developers from local property taxes, a BridgeCity analyst told Crain’s, adding that condos were still a possibility.

Tenants don’t pose much of an issue for Watermark; all of the building’s tenants have either vacated or will be doing so imminently, according to the BridgeCity analyst. Occupants have included Constangy, Brooks, Smith & Prophete, Thelab and coworking company Spaces, though it’s unclear who’s left.

Sign Up for the undefined Newsletter

Watermark did not respond to requests for comment from either outlet.

The property last traded hands in 2017 when a fund managed by Normandy Real Estate Partners purchased a majority stake in it for $100 million. The fund was spun out as part of Cannon Hill after PIMCO took Columbia Property Trust — which itself acquired Normandy — private in 2022.

Three months ago, Landau’s Watermark agreed to acquire Brooklyn’s Hanson Place Central United Methodist Church at 144 Saint Felix Street in Fort Greene for $15 million. Its plans were unclear at the time, but the site has more than 164,000 square feet of development rights.

Holden Walter-Warner

Read more

Watermark Capital Agrees to Buy Fort Greene Church
New York
Watermark Capital agrees to buy Fort Greene church 
Top 10 NYC Neighborhoods for Commercial-to-Resi Conversions
New York
Where are commercial-to-resi conversions happening?
New York
Normandy taking $100M majority stake in Dumbo Heights building