City rejects micro homes project in Tenderloin

Board of supervisors worry 316-unit development would become "tech dorms"

San Francisco /
Oct.October 06, 2021 01:49 PM
450 O’Farrell Street, San Francisco, CA (Gensler)

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors voted unanimously to reject a group home development in Tenderloin.

The board said the tiny residences would become “tech dorms” for transient workers instead of being used as family housing, the San Francisco Chronicle reported. Critics said the area already has multiple hotels and that families with children who have been moving to the area need larger and more permanent homes.

The project, submitted by Fifth Church of Christ, Scientist and Forge Development Partners, called for a 13-story group home development with more than 300 micro units to be built above a new ground-floor church. The building that now stands at 450 O’Farrell Street would have been demolished.

The city’s Planning Commission issued a conditional use authorization in June. But the Tenderloin Housing Clinic appealed the decision, saying the units, which were to be rented for more than $3,000 a month, would be “temporary corporate housing disguised as permanent residences.”

Opponents said the development would take advantage of a loophole in the city planning code that allows developers to exceed density limits for group housing by building communal kitchens instead of providing them in the individual units.

District 6 Supervisor Matt Haney, who represents the Tenderloin area, said he worked with the planning staff to increase the sizes of the units while maintaining the group housing status. That didn’t prove feasible.

“The vague definition of group housing made that very challenging,” Haney told the Chronicle. “We have come to the conclusion that the conditional use authorization does not meet the needs of the neighborhood.”

District 3 Supervisor Aaron Peskin said the project would add to “a glut of group housing in the Tenderloin and Mid-Market areas” that already has a high turnover rate. Peskin also argued that since the neighborhood has the highest level of food-insecurity in the city, homes without cooking facilities and adequate food storage would cause more harm than good.

[SFChronicle] — Victoria Pruitt 





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Lake Tahoe (iStock)
    Tahoe mulls more caps on short-term rentals amid housing crisis
    Tahoe mulls more caps on short-term rentals amid housing crisis
    Bob Staedler, principal, Silicon Valley Synergy; 199 Bassett Street in San Jose (LinkedIn, Google Maps)
    Site of San Jose residential project faces foreclosure auction
    Site of San Jose residential project faces foreclosure auction
    Renderings of Balboa Reservoir (top left), Nellie Hannon Gateway, Emeryville (bottom left) and The Kelsey Civic Center (right) (Balboa Reservoir, RCD Housing, The Kelsey, iStock)
    California affordable housing projects get $808M in cap-and-trade funds
    California affordable housing projects get $808M in cap-and-trade funds
    A photo illustration of 2828 Vallejo Street in Pacific Heights (Redfin, iStock)
    Pacific Heights eight-bedroom from 1880s gets $8.5M price cut
    Pacific Heights eight-bedroom from 1880s gets $8.5M price cut
    (iStock)
    Boston may soon top San Francisco in rents
    Boston may soon top San Francisco in rents
    Renderings of the Santa Clara Station Project and Republic Metropolitan's Kelly Macy (City of Santa Clara, Republic Metropolitan)
    Republic Metropolitan sues Santa Clara over canceled 240-unit apartment project
    Republic Metropolitan sues Santa Clara over canceled 240-unit apartment project
    A $22 Million Versailles-Inspired Mansion Owned by Mervyn’s Department Store Founder Sells in 11 Days (Private Atherton Estate)
    A $22 million Versailles-inspired Atherton mansion sells in 11 days
    A $22 million Versailles-inspired Atherton mansion sells in 11 days
    Developer Bruce Dorfman and Belvedere Island (Civil and Environmental Engineering - The University of Michigan, LoopNet, iStock)
    Mixed-income housing proposed for California’s richest city
    Mixed-income housing proposed for California’s richest city
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...