Staycationers sue luxury rental service for “abysmal” Malibu getaway

LA couple alleges Luxury Vacation Homes cheated them out of $160K

Los Angeles /
Jan.January 05, 2021 03:16 PM
Photo illustration of 27112 Malibu Cove Colony Drive in Malibu (Photos via Realtor)
Photo illustration of 27112 Malibu Cove Colony Drive in Malibu (Photos via Realtor)

Two very peeved vacationers are suing a luxury rental property service alleging that shabby Malibu accommodations ruined their glitzy Covid staycation.

Los Angeles residents Barry and Rena Plost expected a pampered “getaway” in Malibu, paying Luxury Vacation Homes more than $160,000 to deliver a beautiful home, a butler, daily maid service, and a champagne welcome for their two-week stay.

But according to a federal lawsuit filed in New York’s Eastern District Court, LVH instead defrauded the Plosts, renting them a 3,400-square-foot problem-plagued home at 27112 Malibu Cove Colony Drive the company did not own.

Expectation and reality of 27112 Malibu Cove Colony Drive in Malibu

Overlooking the Pacific Ocean, Malibu has some of the priciest real estate in Los Angeles. Because the rental market was tight at the time of the Plost’s early September stay, LVH was unable to find a suitable property in its own portfolio, the suit alleges.

So, the New York-based company “performed inadequate diligence” and allowed for “multiple layers of middlemen” between itself and the owners, according to the suit. The complaint alleges LVH seized on the Plost’s desire to escape the stress of the coronavirus, overcharging the would-be vacationers to the tune of $80,000.

The couple seeks $164,400, along with damages to be determined by the court. Their attorneys declined to comment. LVH did not return a request to comment.

When the couple arrived at the Malibu home on Sept. 1, they were met with overflowing trash containers, lights that didn’t function properly, and dead plants in the window planters, the suit alleges. The refrigerator hadn’t been cleaned out, the cabinets were scuffed, and rust covered the metal furniture, patio railing, electrical outlets and floor vents, according to the suit.

Things continued to deteriorate, according to court papers. LVH sent a handyman to address some of the issues, but by 4 a.m. the next morning, the couple awoke to the sound of an “incessant chirping” from the smoke alarm’s low battery signal.

In the days that followed, as the weather forecast predicted 100-degree temperatures, the air conditioning in the home was “temporary, inadequate and an eye sore,” the filing states. Adding insult to injury, the home’s TV programming was “limited,” the lawsuit alleges.

LVH took responsibility for the “unsafe and uninhabitable” condition of the vacation rental, according to the suit, and promised to promptly return the couple’s money. That refund never arrived.

The couple investigated LVH on its own, and claims the firm does not own the home it had rented, according to the suit. The property typically rented for $20,000 a week, the lawsuit alleges, though Zillow pegs the monthly rent for the three-bedroom, three-and-a-half bathroom home at $33,000. The property last sold in 2016 for $6.7 million, and was listed for $7.7 million last February.






    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Mohamed Hadid and 901 Strada Vecchia Road (Getty, Google Maps)
    Demolish this: Hadid’s embattled spec mansion lists as teardown
    Demolish this: Hadid’s embattled spec mansion lists as teardown
    Rober Reffkin and J. Gregory Maffei (Getty, Linkedin, iStock)
    Compass poached brokers with bait-and-switch, ex-agent alleges
    Compass poached brokers with bait-and-switch, ex-agent alleges
    From left, Michael Rosenfeld and Century Plaza, Jose Huizar and City Hall, Jeff Bezos and 1801 Angelo Drive (Getty Images)
    LA’s biggest real estate stories of 2020
    LA’s biggest real estate stories of 2020
    Red Hot Chili Peppers bassist Flea — real name Michael Balzary — sold his compound for $20 million (Getty, iStock)
    Flea sells Malibu estate for $20M
    Flea sells Malibu estate for $20M
    Neil Shekhter of NMS Properties, who is involved in the lawsuit. (Kevin Scanlon)
    Landlords sue Santa Monica over “arbitrary” ban on short-term rentals
    Landlords sue Santa Monica over “arbitrary” ban on short-term rentals
    Clockwise from top left: 1801 Angelo Drive, 911 North Foothill Road, 1025 Loma Vista Drive and 1175 North Hillcrest Road (Google Maps)
    Bezos, Geffen, Katzenberg dominate LA’s biggest resi sales of 2020
    Bezos, Geffen, Katzenberg dominate LA’s biggest resi sales of 2020
    Nile Niami and "The One" mansion (Getty)
    Niami’s “The One” to hit market
    Niami’s “The One” to hit market
    Redfin's Glenn Kelman
    Redfin’s latest challenge: Defending its employment practices in court
    Redfin’s latest challenge: Defending its employment practices in court
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...