Appeals court rules LA County may restrict outdoor dining

Decision reverses lower court decision requiring officials conduct risk-benefit analysis

Los Angeles /
Mar.March 11, 2021 09:00 AM
(Getty, iStock/Illustration by Alexis Manrodt for The Real Deal)
(Getty, iStock/Illustration by Alexis Manrodt for The Real Deal)

In the latest round of the battle over coronavirus regulations, Los Angeles County health officials may restrict outdoor dining if Covid case counts rise.

That was the ruling from a state appeals court, which reversed an L.A. County Superior Court decision from December, according to the Los Angeles Times.

The lower court had compelled the county to conduct a risk-benefit analysis before seeking to extend its ban on outdoor dining. That decision had no practical implications at the time because California’s stay-at-home order superseded the local ban on outdoor dining. Superior Court Judge James Chalfant at the time wrote that the county ban was “an abuse” of emergency powers.

The recent decision, however, ruled that county health officials were correct in their action.

“We now hold that courts should be extremely deferential to public health authorities, particularly during a pandemic and particularly where, as here, the public health authorities have demonstrated a rational basis for their actions,” Justice Brian Currey wrote in his March 1 opinion.

The case stems from two lawsuits filed in November, one by the California Restaurant Association and the other by the Downtown L.A. restaurant, Engine Co. No. 28. Both filings sought to strike down the outdoor dining ban.

Attorney Mark Geragos, who owns Engine Co. No. 28, is representing both parties. He is also representing a Sherman Oaks restaurant owner in her lawsuit against the state’s outdoor dining ban.

L.A. County isn’t backing down. A week after lifting its ban on outdoor dining in January, the county sued two restaurants that they allege violated the rules, and directing them to show they have complied with the measures.

[LAT] — Dennis Lynch


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Hotel union asks feds for answers on Relevant Group’s EB-5
Hotel union asks feds for answers on Relevant’s EB-5
Hotel union asks feds for answers on Relevant’s EB-5
Home prices continue to increase (iStock)
Southern California ekes out another record on home price
Southern California ekes out another record on home price
(Montage Hotels)
State-owned China outfit in $340M refi on Montage Laguna Beach
State-owned China outfit in $340M refi on Montage Laguna Beach
Mayer Corporation's Robert Mayer and the Hyatt House Hotel at 220 Trojan Way (OCBC, CBRE)
Westbrook Partners provides $61.5M refinance for Hyatt hotel at USC’s Boyle Heights campus
Westbrook Partners provides $61.5M refinance for Hyatt hotel at USC’s Boyle Heights campus
Newmark Director Greg Morgan and Canyon Partners’ Nick Pappas (Getty, LinkedIn via Morgan, Pappas)
Newmark expands Lodging Capital Markets Group to LA
Newmark expands Lodging Capital Markets Group to LA
The mandate will take effect on November 4th (Getty)
City of LA’s vaccine mandate will apply to all indoor retailers
City of LA’s vaccine mandate will apply to all indoor retailers
Councilmember Joe Busciano and Council President Nury Martinez (Getty, Busciano)
LA delays vote on strict vaccine requirement for indoor spaces
LA delays vote on strict vaccine requirement for indoor spaces
The end of California's eviction moratorium is quickly approaching (Getty)
Renters urged to apply for aid ahead of eviction moratorium expiration
Renters urged to apply for aid ahead of eviction moratorium expiration
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...