Civil trial over $320M Angel Stadium development deal set

Hearing on whether City of Anaheim violated state open meetings law slated to open tomorrow

Los Angeles /
Mar.March 01, 2022 03:00 PM
Arte Moreno with Angel's Stadium (Getty, iStock)
Arte Moreno with Angel’s Stadium (Getty, iStock)

A residents’ group has filed last-minute legal briefs ahead of a March 2 trial to support its claim that the City of Anaheim violated state laws during its $320-million deal to sell Angel Stadium.

An Orange County Superior Court judge will hear opening arguments Tuesday in a lawsuit filed by the People’s Homeless Task Force OC, alleging Anaheim officials broke state open meetings laws when deciding to sell the property and negotiate terms of the sale, the Orange County Register reported.

The new briefs take aim at Anaheim’s contention that all its discussions and negotiations of the stadium deal were legal. The city rejects the lawsuit’s claims.

“We have always held this is a meritless lawsuit meant to undermine an open, public process for a stadium site sale that is widely supported by our community,” Anaheim spokesman Mike Lyster told the newspaper. “Nothing has changed, and we stand by our process.”

A victory for the residents’ group could scuttle the deal between the city and Angels Baseball, owner of the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim franchise, now in escrow.

In December 2019, the City Council approved the deal to sell the 150-acre stadium property to SRB Management, a company controlled by Angels owner Arte Moreno, who plans to redevelop the facility with additions of commercial and residential developments. The city voted to trade its stadium for $150 million in cash and $170 million in community benefits, including funds for affordable housing and a 7-acre park.

In the court case, both sides dispute whether City Hall followed the state’s open meetings law known as the Brown Act, which allows the public to weigh in on policy decisions.

Anaheim Councilmember Jose Moreno and former city manager Chris Zapata have both testified in written statements that the council majority decided to sell the stadium in a private closed-door session months before the city claimed it engaged in formal negotiations.

Last month, Anaheim attorneys called for the statements that the council decided to sell in secret be stricken from the public record, arguing they violated rules barring the disclosure of what happens during closed-door meetings.

Late Monday, task force attorney Kelly Aviles filed a brief arguing the declarations from Moreno and Zapata were covered by state whistleblower protections. He said the law allows officials to reveal confidential discussions if they believe illegal action might have taken place.

The brief also counters a contention by the city that its “team of negotiators” was actually an informal group led by Anaheim Mayor Harry Sidhu, and therefore didn’t fall under the state open meetings law.

Aviles’ filing called the city’s argument “a fabrication intended to mislead” the court.

It pointed to a June 4, 2019, city press release saying the city had “put together a negotiating team” made up of Sidhu, Zapata and City Attorney Rob Fabela.

Records show the team met several times to discuss the stadium deal, Aviles wrote, and if there was no negotiating team, “how does the city explain how the deal was negotiated?”

City officials have said they expect escrow on the sale to close early this year. That would allow SRB Management to revamp Angel Stadium and build hotels, restaurants, shops and offices, and more than 5,000 homes over the next several decades. https://therealdeal.com/la/2020/06/25/la-angels-have-a-plan-to-build-an-anaheim-neighborhood-from-scratch/

The lawsuit asks the court to nullify the $320-million deal, so it can be redone with proper public notice and input. Anaheim contends it would be wrong to scuttle the deal, because the city didn’t break the law.

Superior Court Judge David A. Hoffer will hear the case March 2.
[Orange County Register] – Dana Bartholomew





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    A photo illustration of the recently nixed mixed-use complex at 27001 La Paz Road in Mission Viejo (ValueRock Realty, iStock)
    South OC city puts kibosh on mixed-use housing plans
    South OC city puts kibosh on mixed-use housing plans
    Renderings of the project at 8500 Santa Monica Blvd (Tighe Architects)
    Six-story apartments eyed at Santa Monica and La Cienega
    Six-story apartments eyed at Santa Monica and La Cienega
    Anaheim Angels owner Arte Moreno and rendering of new stadium site (SRB Management, Getty Images)
    City cuts new affordable housing deal with Moreno on Angel Stadium sale
    City cuts new affordable housing deal with Moreno on Angel Stadium sale
    Mayor Eric Garcetti and LA County General Hospital at 1200 State Street (Getty)
    LA County looks at redeveloping historic General Hospital
    LA County looks at redeveloping historic General Hospital
    AvalonBay's Timothy J. Naughton and Abode Communities' Robin Hughes with rendering of Legacy Village project at Tustin Legacy (AvalonBay Communities, LinkedIn, City of Tustin)
    Developers aim to build 1,200 apartments at former Marine base in OC
    Developers aim to build 1,200 apartments at former Marine base in OC
    Anaheim mayor Harry Sidhu and theTampico Motel at 120 South State College Street (Getty, LoopNet)
    Anaheim buys blighted motel to create affordable housing
    Anaheim buys blighted motel to create affordable housing
    Primestor Development's Arturo Sneider and Panorama Mall at 8389 North Van Nuys Boulevard (Primestor, LinkedIn)
    Primestor plans 4.5M sf makeover for San Fernando Valley mall
    Primestor plans 4.5M sf makeover for San Fernando Valley mall
    Molina Wu Network's John Molina and Community Hospital Long Beach at 1720 Termino Avenue (Facebook, City of Longbeach)
    State demands closed Long Beach hospital be offered to affordable housing builders
    State demands closed Long Beach hospital be offered to affordable housing builders
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...