Judge denies petition to stop Newport Beach residential development

Olen Properties tried to stop the apartment complex by using CEQA

Los Angeles /
Mar.March 21, 2022 08:13 AM
Olen Properties' Igor Olenicoff with  4400 Von Karman (The Picerne Group, iStock)
Olen Properties’ Igor Olenicoff with 4400 Von Karman (The Picerne Group, iStock)

A judge has denied a petition to stop an apartment complex from being built in Newport Beach.

Olen Properties sued the city on environmental grounds after officials approved an apartment complex at the Koll Center business park near John Wayne Airport, the Mercury News reported. The owner of the firm, billionaire real estate tycoon Igor Olenicoff, said the city didn’t adequately address the potential negative environmental impact of noise, traffic and air pollution.

Judge William Claster denied Olen’s petition and ruled that the city’s environmental review process was up to par, paving the way for developer Picerne Group to build a 312-unit complex at 4400 Von Karman Avenue.

Attorney Jennifer Hernandez, who works for Picerne, said the lawsuit was a case of “CEQA abuse” by using the California Environmental Quality Act to block new housing development.

“We don’t think he has any legitimate basis for suing,” Hernandez, who specializes in CEQA cases, said of Olenicoff. “This is not a guy who has any environmental track record.”

Olen said it had valid concerns about the quality of life for the residents of Newport Beach. “Olen’s national headquarters is in Newport Beach, and many of its employees and investments are also there,” Olen General Counsel Julie Ault told the outlet in an email. “Given that context, the traffic, clean air, noise and other negative impacts of the Picerne project are deeply important to Olen, as they are to everyone who lives and works in this area.”

Ault said the company is reviewing the court ruling and will decide whether to appeal.

The proposed 13-acre development is planned for a parking lot at the intersection of Birch Street and Von Karman Avenue, adjacent to the 10-story office building Olen calls home.

Olen initially sued to stop the development in 2015, claiming it violated Koll Center deed restrictions.

Pro-housing groups joined the lawsuit on behalf of the project, saying it was needed to address the state’s housing shortage. “We don’t think this case was ever about the environment,” People for Housing co-founder Elizabeth Hansburg told the Mercury. “This case was about blocking new housing, especially affordable housing.”

Olen has said its property rights are being violated as the development would replace a 546-car parking lot with two parking structures with 560 parking spaces.

[MN] — Victoria Pruitt 





    Related Articles

    arrow_forward_ios
    Sam Nazarian with 385 Copa de Oro Rd (Westside Estate Agency, Kevin Scanlon, iStock, Illustration by Shea Monahan for The Real Deal)
    Sam Nazarian puts Bel-Air manse on market
    Sam Nazarian puts Bel-Air manse on market
    Pasadena mayor Victor Gordo and attorney general Rob Bonta (iStock, Rob Bonta, City of Pasadena, Illustration by Kevin Cifuentes for The Real Deal)
    Pasadena withstands AG’s slings and arrows on SB 9
    Pasadena withstands AG’s slings and arrows on SB 9
    The property at 10301 Strathmore with Architect Richard Manion (Richard Manion, 10301 Strathmore)
    $25M ask hits mid-market in Holmby Hills
    $25M ask hits mid-market in Holmby Hills
    Tammy Hughes Gustavson and 27628 Pacific Coast Highway (LinkedIn, Coldwell Banker Realty)
    Self-storage billionaire lists Malibu estate in Paradise Cove
    Self-storage billionaire lists Malibu estate in Paradise Cove
    Story Company's Billy Lehman Goodyear and a rendering 1529 Amalfi Drive (Story Company, Aeries Development)
    Custom luxe developer sells mansion in Pacific Palisades
    Custom luxe developer sells mansion in Pacific Palisades
    A photo illustration of the recently nixed mixed-use complex at 27001 La Paz Road in Mission Viejo (ValueRock Realty, iStock)
    South OC city puts kibosh on mixed-use housing plans
    South OC city puts kibosh on mixed-use housing plans
    Michael Gray and 309 Via Lido Soud (Hoag Hospital, Coldwell Banker via Toby Ponnay)
    St. John Knits scion seeks high-water mark on Newport Harbor manse
    St. John Knits scion seeks high-water mark on Newport Harbor manse
    Engelbert Humperdinck in Jayne Mansfield’s famous “Pink Palace” in Holmby Hills back in the day. (Getty)
    Engelbert Humperdinck seeks $6.2M for Bel Air mansion — but it needs work
    Engelbert Humperdinck seeks $6.2M for Bel Air mansion — but it needs work
    arrow_forward_ios

    The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

    Loading...