Bal Harbour Shops seeks to give Saks Fifth Avenue the boot

Whitman Family Development alleges store has taken advantage of pandemic to not pay $1.8M in rent and other expenses

Miami /
Aug.August 24, 2020 02:30 PM
Matthew Whitman Lazenby and Bal Harbour Shops

Matthew Whitman Lazenby and Bal Harbour Shops

One of South Florida’s longest running retail marriages could be headed for a bitter breakup.

For nearly 45 years, Saks Fifth Avenue has anchored Bal Harbour Shops, helping transform the shopping center into one of the most exclusive luxury retail destinations in the world. Now, mall owner Whitman Family Development is poised to end the relationship by filing an eviction lawsuit against Saks in Miami-Dade Circuit Court.

According to the suit, filed last week, Saks hasn’t paid its percentage rent, which is derived from the department store’s net sales, for February, March and April. Saks also owes Bal Harbour Shops for 2019 real estate taxes that the national retailer is supposed to pay as additional expenses under its lease, the lawsuit states.

Bal Harbour Shops alleges Saks owes more than $1.8 million as of July 8. In addition, Whitman Family Development wants Saks to return a portion of an $18 million advance it provided the national retailer to renovate its department store at 9700 Collins Avenue in Bal Harbour.

In a statement, a Saks spokesperson said the company will defend against the lawsuit. “In this situation, we are looking forward to the legal system determining what is fair and reasonable for all parties,” the statement said. “For many years, Saks has been a significant part of the success of Bal Harbour Shops, and we expect to continue to be part of that success for a long time to come.”

Bal Harbour Shops, which is in the midst of a nearly $500 million expansion and renovation, reopened on May 18 after nearly two months of closure due to COVID-19 restrictions in the village and Miami-Dade County. Despite being closed, the Saks department store continued to generate sales, including reporting sales in June that “actually exceeded” reported sales for the same month in 2019, the lawsuit alleges.

In a statement, a Bal Harbour Shops spokesperson said Saks falls under a category of tenant that “made a carefully calculated strategy to intentionally default on lease commitments and seek to use the pandemic as a convenient excuse to evade their financial obligations.”

“Regrettably, Saks Fifth Avenue seems to be such a tenant,” the statement continued. “Saks’ extensive arrearages include long overdue rent that accrued pre-Covid, as well as percentage rent on sales that occurred after Saks re-opened for business after the lifting of closure orders from county and municipal governments.”

Saks steadfastly refused to make any effort to pay any part of its rent despite posting impressive post-Covid sales at Bal Harbour Shops, the statement said. “Bal Harbour Shops has worked tirelessly to ensure our business and our tenants can survive and thrive in this environment,” the statement said. “Regrettably, this injudicious behavior has left us with no other option than to terminate the Saks lease and sue to evict Saks from Bal Harbour Shops.”

On Aug. 4, Hudson Bay Company, Saks’ parent, informed Whitman Family Development owner and Manager General Matthew Whitman Lazenby via letter that the lease did not give the mall owner the authority to demand the $1.8 million. The lease agreement allows Saks to be excused from its obligations if its business is hindered by an Act of God and government shutdowns, according to the letter attached to the lawsuit.

“In this case, [the] tenant was ordered to close its business operations not only in Bal Harbour, but throughout the country,” the letter states. “The result of these governmental orders and restrictions has been devastating.”

Furthermore, the letter states, Saks has recently won favorable court rulings in other U.S. jurisdictions where landlords sought to evict the department store.

In Saks’ statement to The Real Deal, the company spokesperson said Lazenby and the Whitman family have not acted in good faith.

“Not only have they chosen not to adequately assume their fair share of the damages created by the global health crisis still gripping our nation, they have used the press and legal system to bully tenants,” the statement said. “They are upset that Saks Fifth Avenue has not succumbed to their bullying and are continuing to inflict damage to our business and reputation with these actions.”


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
From left: Monroe Capital’s Theodore Koenig, Steve Witkoff, HFZ's Ziel Feldman and Benny Shabtai with the Shore Club (Monroe, Witkoff, HFZ, Getty)
Judge awards $5M to Israeli mogul in HFZ lawsuit over failed Shore Club project in Miami Beach
Judge awards $5M to Israeli mogul in HFZ lawsuit over failed Shore Club project in Miami Beach
Carillon Miami Wellness Resort at 6801 Collins Avenue in Miami Beach (Google Maps, Getty)
Z Capital loses attempt to slap Miami Beach condo owners with $8M assessment
Z Capital loses attempt to slap Miami Beach condo owners with $8M assessment
Domenic Gatto and Banyan Cay Resort and Club (Linkedin, Banyan Cay, Illustration by The Real Deal with Getty)
Developers of troubled West Palm resort project facing $61M foreclosure
Developers of troubled West Palm resort project facing $61M foreclosure
KAR Properties' Shahab Karmely and  Suffolk Construction's  Peter Tuffo with 2000 Ocean  (Suffolk, KAR, Getty)
Suffolk sues for $16M, alleging unpaid work at Shahab Karmely’s Hallandale Beach condo project
Suffolk sues for $16M, alleging unpaid work at Shahab Karmely’s Hallandale Beach condo project
From left: Witkoff’s Steve Witkoff and Monroe Capital’s Theodore Koenig with the Shore Club
Witkoff, Monroe sued over alleged “crooked and secretive land grab” of Shore Club in South Beach
Witkoff, Monroe sued over alleged “crooked and secretive land grab” of Shore Club in South Beach
Adeena Weiss Ortiz and map view of 4865 Northwest 7th Street in Miami (WeissOrtiz Law, Google Maps)
Caroline Weiss locked in legal conflict with daughter over $21M loan tied to massive Blue Lagoon development
Caroline Weiss locked in legal conflict with daughter over $21M loan tied to massive Blue Lagoon development
Miami-Dade County Mayor Daniella Levine Cava, Attorney
Miami-Dade may help renters in eviction court secure attorneys
Miami-Dade may help renters in eviction court secure attorneys
Codina Partners’ Armando Codina and Ana-Marie Codina Barlick with 5350 Park (Codina Partners, Downtown Doral)
Miami-Dade judge hits Codina Partners’ affiliate with $6M in damages
Miami-Dade judge hits Codina Partners’ affiliate with $6M in damages
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...